Fantasia -- If You Can't Say Something Nice ...

I watched AI last night and could not wait for her performance to be over! I could not understand a word she was trying to say..err...sing. It was AWFUL

I agree with those that say Fantasia should not have won. She was horrible then and worse now. One person remarked that Simon was clapping. If he was it was just because he was so glad she was finished. She really is one unattractive woman.

SIMON'S FACE WAS PRICELESS...........THE WAY HE WAS LOOKING AT RANDY AS IF HE WERE SAYING WTF? I WOULD OF LOVED FOR SEACREST TO ASK WHAT THE JUDGES THOUGHT!!

Re comment 68....I don't pay for the site advertisers do based on how many people hit the site...if he's telling fans to "piss off" then he is telling that to the people who pay him. Yes, he does have the right to tell me that and I accept it, but I don't think people should read believing he does it for the "fans" when he really could care less

what the freak was up with her? OMG!!! That was the most disgusting performance I have ever seen in my life!!!! **chokes on her bagel**

Can I take my vote back for Fantasia from that Idol season? Did anyone understand what she was singing?

she was AWFUL! What a mess!

I had the same look on my face watching her....She is HORRIBLE! So when they showed Simon's face, it was classic!

Ya so look dawg...for me it was just so so. And it was a little pitchy in spots.

I haven't been following her career, was that performance something from an off off Broadway show she's in? It was pretty awful for me. I enjoy music in all different genres - as long as it's done well. That performance was a mess.

Next to Fantasia's performance, Kristy Lee Cook's "Eight Days A Week" could go platinum!
Simon's face said it all, and I am sure he was eating a nice healthy serving of crow last night.

FANTASIA SUCKED BALLS!!!!
SIMON SAID IT ALL WITH HIS EXPRESSION, I LIVE ALONE, MY NEIGHBORS PROBABLY THOUGHT I LOST MY MIND LAUGHING SO HARD AT THE WHOLE THING. PRICELESS!!!!

PLEEEEEEEEEZE AI GOD, DON'T LET ARCHIE WIN!

GO DAVID COOK!!!

Fantasia is a very skillful talented artist who has overcome any struggles she faced as a young black woman coming up. I applaud her for her efforts and for those of you who has a promblem with her hair color, it takes major confidence to rock shades like that. It sounds like you think black people only smoke crack or cocaine. Stop the racist attitudes.

FANTASIA LOOKED **AWFUL** WITH HER ** RED HAIR***.... IT WAS QUITE GROSS......

Haters shut up with your facing problems due to being black it has nothing to do with that YOU are the racist