Nicollette Punished by Michael Bolton Song

9/12/2008 12:45 PM PDT BY TMZ STAFF
She doesn't have to pretend to like his music anymore, but Michael Bolton songs still haunt Nicollette Sheridan.
Nicollette Sheridan: Click to watch
After trying to find out if Bolton's hair had anything to do with the break-up, the paps busted out one of his ... uh.. classics(?) outside The Ivy -- Nic, in her Carmen Sandiego hat, wasn't laughing.