TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Jessica vs. Jennifer vs. Brooke

Who'd You Rather?

7/4/2010 6:35 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

Jessica Simpson, Jennifer Garner and Brooke Shields all showed up Friday night for the grand opening of the Casino Club at The Greenbrier in White Sulphur Springs, WV.

0703_wwyr_getty
Question is ...

58 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

James    

Jessica Simpson for me. I think she's hot.

1488 days ago
2.

Gloria Unread    

Jessica Simpson, by a long shot! She could be forty pounds heavier and still be hotter than those two.

Brooke Shields is way past her prime, while Jennifer Garner has *never* had a prime to begin with. Garner has got a horse face that could easily rival SJP. I don't understand how she gets put into movies as the sex symbol/love interest. There isn't one single attractive feature on her as far as I can tell, and she's not that great of an actress, either. I can't believe she's winning the poll at this point, but it's still early...

1488 days ago
3.

Darvon    

Jessica Napalm Simpson, of course.

1488 days ago
4.

Darvon    

Jennifer is winning the pole because someone is voting over and over again just to pull a prank on Jessica.
There can not be only 3 comments out of 3817 people voting.

1488 days ago
5.

jc    

Jennifer Garner is a hag compared to Jessica Simpson, and a whole lot older.

1487 days ago
6.

Derek    

I'm with Gloria Unread (#2). I just do NOT understand why Jennifer Garner is winning this poll. My guess is that she is in the center and it has a psychological advantage by making it seem as if she is the "alpha" female in the group.

Jessica Simpson should be winning this poll by a long shot!

1487 days ago
7.

TMZFan    

I love Jennifer, but you can't forget the Sexual Naplam ;)

1487 days ago
8.

Josi Coyote Verlingieri    

I love Jennifer and Brooke's natural beauty. Even with no makeup they are natural beauties.

1487 days ago
9.

Josi Coyote Verlingieri    

Jennifer is so beautiful because she radiates beauty inside and out. Look at her kids they radiate her smile too.

1487 days ago
10.

devon    

i don't know wtf jessica's eating but her face is turning in the incredible hulk. get your fat ass to the gym. her prime came and WENT in just a few years.

brooke's the oldest and the hottest of the group.

1487 days ago
11.

Philster    

I'd have to audition all three before I could post a judgment.

1487 days ago
12.

Tabloid Diva    

JG needs to cover up those big ears.
JS needs to lose weight and get that bump taken outta her beak.
BS is aging gracefully, looks great.
But in the end, who really cares??

1487 days ago
13.

rar    

What I'd rather: that TMZ stop these idiotic polls pitting women "against" one another. Childish.

1487 days ago
14.

Carl    

Wow, that is a terrible shot of all of them even though it is posed! Jennifer Garner looks especially bad. If it is just based on this pic I'd say Jessica, but normally I'd say Jennifer.

1487 days ago
15.

lawntamersinc    

This is unrelated, but I saw Brooke Shields on a show last week (called The Middle, I think) She played a trashy neighbor & she was hilarious. I was laughing out loud.

Just sayin'.

1487 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web