Gerard vs. Hugh: Who'd You Rather?

I so miss the "Butlered" song. Is there a royalty problem?

i just literally laughed out loud with this one, becuz i love both these men!!!!! when ppl ask me who i'm attracted to, i always say "gerald butler or hugh jackman" so i can't choose. love you both!

They both look edible...or lickable :P and Gerard looks better than usual here, but he's a bit of an ass. Therefore I chose Hugh who seems more personable.

I'd choose Hugh. Oh wait a minute, I'm a guy.

Thanks like asking me to choose between chocolate & ice cream. They are both yummy!

To post #7 LOL. Never heard it put that way before.

TMZ pulled a fast one here. I wont vote, I will declare both!

"as gay as a gay parrot....?" hilarious!

They're both beautiful men. I can't decide.

How about both at once?

(1,2,3 Peter Paul & Mary)

*wink*

I hate Gerard's hair, im gonna say Hugh!

They both have their place in my Top 10 To Do List.
Gerry @ #1 and Hugh #3 With Craig Ferguson #2. I guess I got a thing for blue eyed Scots.

Toughest decision . . EVER!!!! But I gotta go with Hugh.

Who'd you rather? There should be an option for Both.

Yikes, they say Hugh's gay, so I'll go with the straight guy! Butler's sexy as sheesh in "Phantom of the Opera."

Oooooo daddy. Looks like a hunk samish in the making. WOOOF!