Metcalfe vs. Jenner: Who'd You Rather?! Metcalfe vs. Jenner Who'd You Rather?! 11/7/2009 8:53 AM PT Young Hollywood hunks Jesse Metcalfe, 30, and Brody Jenner, 26, bro'd out at the same event in Berlin on Thursday. Question is ... See Also Kate vs. Drew: Who'd You Rather?ZZ Top vs. Slash: Who'd You Rather? Share on Facebook Share on X Brody Jenner Jesse Metcalfe Beauty Who'd You Rather?