It's the picture that launched a killer argument in the TMZ newsroom this morning -- Hayden Panettiere, cottage cheese-leader?! 
Watch the debate unfold in the video below, then vote in our two polls -- and let TMZ know what you think!
1. first wow im am honored
Posted at 5:24PM on Oct 24th 2007 by omofmom
2. would still hit that in a new york minute. it shows she is a real person
and eats pizza. besides, who cares about a little leg cheese when the
lights are out.
Posted at 5:25PM on Oct 24th 2007 by bomber
3. The camera does not lie, people! Photoshop and other image editing software can do wonders but I highly doubt this picture has been altered.
Posted at 5:25PM on Oct 24th 2007 by Professional Photographer
4. You TMZ people are nuts. She's way to young and thin to have that on her legs.
Posted at 5:26PM on Oct 24th 2007 by chris
5. its people like you who cause girls to have eating problems. she has meat on her bones and this is a cause of a huge discussion in a tmz newsroom? sad. maybe you should be concentrating on how BONE SKINNEY people are and not criticize how an average person looks like
Posted at 5:38PM on Oct 24th 2007 by bam
6. looks like a little cellulite but um so what? She has a great body, shes not a fitness queen.......Most chicks have it skinny or fat when their bodies are positioned in certain ways.....doesnt make a difference
Posted at 5:27PM on Oct 24th 2007 by ms wonderland
7. No way that's cellulite. Looks more like her thighs have shading from sitting down. The shorts are very short, so that is the best theory. Regardless, the girl is hot.
Posted at 5:35PM on Oct 24th 2007 by BTExpress
8. Had she been sitting on a rough surface right beforehand? I know the back of my legs look like that when I first stand up after sitting on something rough like a concrete bench. Honestly, Hyden does NOT have bad legs, and this is not something I think TMZ should be posting. TMZ is known for the big stories, not the dumb crap that most other people blog about. Let Perez Hilton discuss this, it isn't anything TMZ should be concerned with.
Posted at 5:28PM on Oct 24th 2007 by Jac
9. to add to my previous comment i have the "honor" of being in the medical field (ob/gyn) and i've assisted in many a papsmear and tons of chicks in GOOD shape, once they are in stirups u can SEE cellulite on the bottom of their thighs...it doesnt mean anything
Posted at 5:29PM on Oct 24th 2007 by MS WONDERLAND
10. please she does not have cellulite. Most women do have cellulite so this is absolutely ridiculous...do you guys at TMZ have more important things to do. You guys have way too much time on your hands.
Posted at 5:29PM on Oct 24th 2007 by geezwhatnexttmz
11. It looks like she just got out of a car or something. Sometimes i have marks on the back of my legs and thighs after getting up from sitting on a couch, and they are present for some time.
Still hit it though.
Posted at 6:01PM on Oct 24th 2007 by tasty
12. for all we know that could be the inpressions of a seat she had just been sitting in... even if it's not... then cellulite might be a natural part of life (what do i know - i'm only 20).
Posted at 5:31PM on Oct 24th 2007 by morgan
13. No.........................No................she is to young for cottage cheese legs. She must wait until she is a least 30 and has had kids!!!!!!!!
Posted at 5:31PM on Oct 24th 2007 by No Dairy Products
14. There should be another option on the poll called "Great Photo." Shes fine.....
Posted at 5:32PM on Oct 24th 2007 by Ya Heard
15. You guys suck for putting that up. She's 18, can't you be a little bit nice. I mean, that isn't even news! Seriously, cellulite is NOT news. This was Perez Hilton low.
Posted at 5:33PM on Oct 24th 2007 by Bb
