1. Am I the only one who finds this kid bogus? Yes, he has a decent singing voice, but everytime I see his face and hear him talk I just want to hit mute on my TV.

Posted at 9:39AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Cristina

2. TMZ,leave this boy alone..so what if he has had talent for years..Something Harvey needs to work on,with this trashey ass website..

Posted at 9:40AM on Apr 9th 2008 by bella

3. We all know that the contestants don't sing original pieces on a weekly basis--why do you keep beating this dead horse TMZ?

Posted at 9:41AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Eli

4. This kid is amazing and so young. WHY do you enjoy pick, pick, picking at his performances? You may indeed be picking on the next AI.

Posted at 9:44AM on Apr 9th 2008 by chichi

5. Did John Secada sing this song??? David never said who sang it last night Cant belive THAT didnt make the news!

Posted at 9:45AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Star

6. He did not say that he just found this song. He said that he had several inspirational songs to choose from and this one stood out. You love to twist things around to create drama; pick on somebody who deserves it like those cheerleaders who beat up that girl. They need to learn their lesson.

Posted at 9:48AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Kel

7. Cristina I sooooo agree with you!!

This kid is way to OVERRATED.... I don't think he is that spectacular. I find him down right annoying and just want him to go away.

David Archuleta just go away!

Posted at 9:49AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Huh....

8. Cristina I sooooo agree with you!!

This kid is way to OVERRATED.... I don't think he is that spectacular. I find him down right annoying and just want him to go away.

David Archuleta just go away!

Posted at 9:49AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Huh....

9. He didn't say he just found the song...he said he had a hard time picking a song...geez...and so what if he has done the songs before, he does them very good so why ruin a good thing? Come up with something else to complain about...

Posted at 9:54AM on Apr 9th 2008 by KK

10. liars and cheats , this whole season suks. I vote that Idol go away for good.

Posted at 9:57AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Mike

11. I totally agree with Christina (#2) and Huh (#8). Form the beginning, I have not been entertained at all by David A. Yes, he has very good singing skills, but he's boring. I do think he has a good chance of winning because the tweens think he is cute. if he does win, I do think he has the ability to produce an excellent Amercian Idol Christmas cd (which will make A.I. lots of money).

Posted at 10:00AM on Apr 9th 2008 by PrincessBarbie

12. David Archuleta has a very nice voice. But he's lmited in the sense that he only seems to sing Ballads well. Maybe as he gets older that will change. To me the best singers with the most range are Michael Johns and David Cook. I think both of them can sing anythng and still sound great !!!

Posted at 10:01AM on Apr 9th 2008 by elisa

13. I agree that David is over-rated. Why are the judges constantly drooling over him? I just don't see it. If I were going to buy an album of one of the contestants, it would be M. Johns, D. Cook, Brook, or the Irish gal.

Posted at 10:07AM on Apr 9th 2008 by don't see it

14. who sings that song????????

Posted at 10:07AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Star

15. I do not think he's as good as they are making him out to be. He's no where even close to as good as Carly or David Cook. His loud inhales drive me nuts! The "I'm shy and don't know what to do with all this girly attention" is getting way old. Just eat it up like every other 17-year-old boy would do. I just don't think he's mature enough in his performing to pull of a career just yet. Plus, they keep bagging Syesha and other performers who are clearly better than him, yet he gets minimal criticism. Just goes to show that the judges can really sway the competition more than people seem to realize.

Posted at 10:09AM on Apr 9th 2008 by CatP