TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Navarro vs. McLean

Who'd You Rather?

10/17/2009 5:01 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

Dave Navarro and Backstreet Boy A.J. McLean got shady at the same event in L.A. on Thursday.

Dave Navarro and AJ McLean
Question is ....

33 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

MissCarter    

AJ!!! Of Course!!!!!
I love Backstreet Boys!!! But also AJ looks better!!!

1743 days ago
17.

whocares    

Isn't Navarro bi? I'd rather be with someone who is straight. Navarro is too risky for your health.

1743 days ago
18.

Molinete    

you´re georgeus! the best arround the world!!
c u soon in spain!!

1743 days ago
19.

momofthree    

for all future polls about "Who'd you rather", PLEASE give us the option for NEITHER!!!

1743 days ago
20.

Dani    

AJ used to be hot as hell, but then again, I was like 12 when he was a backstreet boy. I've gotta say Dave now

1743 days ago
21.

Lindsay Blohan    

Dave Navarro looks like Roseanne Barr with a goatee pasted on.

1743 days ago
22.

Summer    

AJ is my man through thick and thin. i have no idea who this other guy is. and for all who said, AJ was an addict. now he's not. he's been sober for so long and i am so proud of him. being in the limelight is so hard and i hope that AJ wins. he's so gorgeous. but i do want to know who picked his picture. bad choice....

1743 days ago
23.

vickycarter    

KTBSPA!!! AJ ARGENTINA LOVES YOUU!!!

1742 days ago
24.

SusieK    

Oh man, I had to vote twice coz I've met them both, I've hugged them both, and I love them both! And they both wear eyeliner, but AJ does not wear lip liner. Dave might wear lipstick once in a while when he's wearing one of his skirts! *wink*

1742 days ago
25.

SusieK    

Uh, RECOVERING drug addicts, mr. magoo. Everyone makes mistakes, and these two guys have paid a heavy price by both almost dying from overdoses. They're human, just like the rest of us, and thus, they make mistakes. Like I said, I've met them both and I respect them for making positive changes in their lives. They're both talented musicians and I really enjoy the music they both make. And to Seth regarding what Dave said, I must've missed that, and it was probably said either in jest or it happened when he was still using drugs.

1742 days ago
26.

@margiemarina    

AJ McLean rather???? i don't think so.... i love it AJ, is the best, Dave he is the rather!!!! kisses from Lima-Peru!!!!

1742 days ago
27.

Bridgett    

really.....REALLY?!?! AK ALL THE WAY BABY!! Dave looks like a creepy ass doll to me ick! and seriously TMZ couldve posted a better picture of AJ! TMZ does his crap on purpose!

1742 days ago
28.

Ohio    

TMZ your Who'd You Rather's these days are hilarious!

1741 days ago
29.

Anna J.    

Maybe if TMZ bothered to use a better pic of AJ where he's not in mid-speech, then maybe you'd have a better picture to represent him. An online buddy met him on the 6th, and in her pics with him, he was so attractive and smiling big. Not that I have anything against Dave Navarro (who is featured in one of my favorite Christina songs of all time, btw), but backstreet loyalty pretty much wins me over every time.

1741 days ago
30.

Jane Doe    

Oh, c'mon people. AJ has always been the fugly one of the Backstreet Boys, I can't believe he got 38% of the vote. Dave has always been hot since the Janes Addiction days, even though he wears makeup and brows are sculpted nicer than mine.

1741 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web