Englund vs. Haley: Who'd You Rather?!

1. Give us the choice of neither will you TMZ????

Posted at 6:01PM on Oct 19th 2009 by Come On!

2. Bad News Bears, Breaking Away, Little Children... JEH is aces in my book.

Posted at 6:09PM on Oct 19th 2009 by IKnowItAll

3. Kelly got old! That means I am old.

Posted at 6:27PM on Oct 19th 2009 by abraham

4. Who'd I rather see as Freddy? I guess I'm interested in the new guy's take on it....that's what you were asking, ...right, TMZ?

Posted at 6:52PM on Oct 19th 2009 by Bobo Frog

5. You REALLY should have a "neither" option. Seriously.

Posted at 10:32PM on Oct 19th 2009 by Estelle

6. You and me, Freddie; I'll tame yer beast!

Posted at 8:39AM on Oct 20th 2009 by Raejean

7. Robert is forever Freddy in my book. The ONLY Freddy worth watching.

Posted at 11:56PM on Oct 19th 2009 by Lexi

8. From the very first moment I saw him in a movie, when he was a child still, I thought that Jackie Earle Haley had to be one of the ugliest human beings I've ever had the misfortune to cast eyes on. Really, it seems like he was genetically bred to have the ugly genes kill off any attractive or average ones trying to take root in his body. Igg, ugg, gives me the willies just thinking about him.

Posted at 9:02PM on Oct 19th 2009 by SianP

9. I call "Hitler" on this one.

Posted at 9:37PM on Oct 19th 2009 by Cali MJ Fan

10. Screw remakes man. Damn, i swear these bitches in hollywood keep it up like this, then everything you love will be a remake. There's only one Freddy Krueger and it's not Jackie. God... that trailer was so gay, it didn't made my day. What's next... cover and entire album by someone? Somebody said Jackie playing freddy was like he was mentally challenge or something. And his voice sucked along with the make up. Why does the 21st century suck so much donkey balls? for all of you out there with the "haters" word, screw you and I am sure I'm not the only one who agrees with this. Originality is dead. We did it all for the money so you can take that honey and stick it up!

Posted at 10:33PM on Oct 19th 2009 by FRED KILLS HITS!

11. I don't see an "ick" button.

Posted at 1:50AM on Oct 20th 2009 by Lori

12. Its sad when you'd rather with Freddy Kruger.

Posted at 8:33AM on Oct 20th 2009 by jcarri07

13. eff that!! id get it on with jackie in a second..mmm something about him....

Posted at 12:04AM on Oct 25th 2009 by brittneypiink

14. definitley robert englund, it'll be like doin' freddy krueger for realz.

Posted at 2:00AM on Oct 20th 2009 by melinda montoya

15. ugly, ugly, ugly, ugly,

Posted at 9:32AM on Oct 20th 2009 by tt