McGowan vs. Smart: Who'd You Rather?

Both actually, but I wouldn't mind going where Marilyn's been.

Amy Smart is so ugly it doesn't matter how much make-up they wear I can see what they really look like. Rose does look strange with red lipstick but most girls do. Amy looks even more ugly in it when you look at her eyes all you see are bags mega oil shine on her face greasy flat wide nose huge forehead and tiny nothing boobs do the math of who is hot.

I'm not specifically a fan of Amy's, but I could never be with anyone who seriously thought that sleeping with Marilyn Manson was a good idea.

The level of sex cooties alone would constitute a planet-threatening biohazard ...

Rose??....What's wrong with her face? Amy...?? She looks sweaty!

you definitely need the both category with these two, and I mean at the same time!

One time Amy Smart showed up at the cafe that I used to manage/wait tables at in Boston. In the flesh, she looked just like anyone else without all that help from makeup artists and hot clothes and other hollywood magic. She is REALLY short and looked more like a Boston University junior rather than a famous actress. She is good at acting, though.

The obvious vote would be for Rose even without knowing Amy's a normy.

you could never know what you might catch from that McGowen thing. all those nasty freaks that bang her. she's probably a walking pitri(spelling?)dish.

59% for Rose and 41% for Amy? Wow, i guess 59% of the people in TMZ are gay...nothing wrong with that...just terrible taste in women.