TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

'Idol' Chick -- Amazing 'Grace'

3/18/2010 2:03 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

Here's "American Idol" standout Siobhan Magnus on Tuesday night's show (left) -- and Debra Messing as Grace Adler in a flashback episode of "Will & Grace" (right).

Siobhan Magnus and Debra Messing
One of them brought out the Lambert cackle to sing "Paint it Black" in an '80s prom dress on Tuesday.

We're just sayin'.

24 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

suzy martinez    

Siobhan, is a bad ass i hope she wins i voted for her and this is the first time i ever voted for someone on american idol she Rocks !!!

1647 days ago
17.

TK    

Well at least this time it's not some ugly, hunchback looking dude (I'm still mad about that!) but I agree... no purpose to this!!

1647 days ago
18.

shell    

This girl is gorgeous. She has great skin, awesome teeth and is beautiful. Looks like a prettier Claire Danes to me. Though when she spoke in her little backhome montage she seemed a little 'slow' to me. She has a great voice and a great look too.

1647 days ago
19.

FlamingoNut    


15. Siobhan, is a bad ass i hope she wins i voted for her and this is the first time i ever voted for someone on american idol she Rocks !!! Posted at 1:21PM on Mar 18th 2010 by suzy martinez

BAD being the operative word. Nails on a chalkboard, barn owl, screeeeeeeeccccccccchhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

1647 days ago
20.

Aredhel_Tari    

Absolute worse rendition of Paint it Black ever. I thought she ruined the song, especially her cackling scream at the end.

1647 days ago
21.

lena    

a true natural talent, i hope she wins......regardless, she'll get a recording contact and get her career going. she's fabulous.

1647 days ago
22.

Xanadu    

All the comments supporting this girl must be her relatives and friends because she sounds AWFUL. I am not a huge fan of Idol but if this beast wins, I will never waste another minute watching it! I totally agree with comment #2 - what she did to Paint It Black was freaking criminal----because she is a FREAK! All her family members need to get over her NOW because she CANNOT SING & her personality is so weak, she even speaks monotone - I too will be so happy when she is voted off but it wont be soon enough!

1647 days ago
23.

Rodney    

She looked a lot more like Sean Young

1646 days ago
24.

Elana Scofield    

Siobhan magnus has really pulled it off here.. I mean who couldn't see that the voice she had on at http://www.SiobhanMagnusidol.com was the idea american idol theme.

1616 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2

Around The Web