Jessica Takes A "Holiday"?

Madonna might be more than a little surprised when she hears the title track and first single off of Jessica Simpson's new album "A Public Affair."

The single appears to bear a striking resemblance to Madonna's 1983 hit "Holiday."  In fact, the songs sounds eerily similar.

From the synth-pop beat to the jangly guitars in the beginning, to the eight-note motifs in the verses to the choruses that begin on an A and the use of the same key (B-minor), the two songs are so similar that, in a highly unscientific poll, every person to whom TMZ played "A Public Affair" identified it as "Holiday."   Will Jellybean Benitez (who produced the original) be getting royalties for this? 

TMZ called a rep for Madonna, but as of yet our calls have not been returned. As for Jessica, her rep tells TMZ "It is a fun summer single and comparing to retro Madonna is flattering!"

But don't trust our ears: You be the judge. Listen to Jessica's "A Public Affair" and Madonna's "Holiday" to compare.



Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 34) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

16. this song is lame. it sounds like one of the cheesey songs that just get put on a pop album to take up space... not a hit from the album. and why doesnt anyone ever write a catchy song for Jessica? her songs are always the cheesey left over songs that it would seem none of the other 'pop princess' girls would want to worry about. and why does she sound like madonna and why is paris tryin to rip off gwens sound?? all a bunch of copy cats who have their music written for them..

Posted at 4:52PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Veronica

17. They sure are similar, then at the end theres a little diana ross too!

Posted at 5:13PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Amy

18. I enjoyed it. I would enjoy it if it were on in the background at a club or resturaunt. and if it came on in the car I'd listen the first few times. I think if it were tweaked with a few bass bumps, etc,like given a club mix vibe it'd be even better. I also think her voice sounds great and to me her voice sounds happy.

Posted at 5:13PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by alcorr

19. How do you guys know for a fact that she didn't sample "Holiday?" The song was just released today, so we don't know for sure. Calling it a rip-off when I'm sure it is a little premature.

Posted at 5:14PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by matthew

20. Bottom Line.......It sucks, I know I won't buy it that's for sure....maybe the little girls will like it though....just not mature enough for my taste.

Posted at 5:14PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Sherry

21. Not even singing lessons can help Jessica Simpson. She oversings, sounds too breathy and annoying. I think I'm allergic to her voice,if there's such a thing. She needs to concentrate on fixing that bird beak she calls a nose. An ass lift wouldn't hurt, she has a flat one.

I hope you get sued 4 ripping off a Madonna song!!!!

Posted at 5:22PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by hilda

22. It IS "Holiday"...it's really too close. I thought instantly it was a re-mix of Holiday.

Posted at 5:32PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by lori

23. Oh y'all need to be quiet and quit bitching! What about Vanilla Ice.....he stole the music in Ice Ice Baby from Queen's song "Under Pressure". Eminem did it, so did Lonestar, Cher and Elton John. I could keep going. THAT'S just what singers do. Get over it! It's not a bad song and hell...it's not like she stole the lyrics.

Posted at 5:42PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Robin

24. Talk about being blatant. I hope Madge sues.

@Nicolle: She did not rip them off. She begged them to let her sample "Gimme, Gimme, Gimme (A Man After Midnight)" they agreed, saying "I see that as a tribute. We almost always say no to these things. Madonna's assistant came over to Sweden and played the track, and it was so catchy that Benny and I immediately said 'Yes'. We have loads of offers like that but we never say yes, but in this case it was so cleverly done."

Source: http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/article/ds27024.html (Google it and you'll find more.)

Posted at 5:51PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Chris

25. it sucks just like she does. it does sound ripped off. i don't like her anyway because i watched the newlyweds. she was a spoiled SLOB, the only thing that made her human was being with a normal guy like nick. she was critical down to his music, how he decorated and his opinions. then they show her leaving adam levine's hotel in a man's shirt? disgusting. i'm glad she's showing her true colors by posing like a slut on maxim. when she was married she did the mag but fully clothed, no cleavage. honey, just because you like the missionary position DOESN'T make you a missionary! "public affair" sounds right to me.

Posted at 5:55PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by eli

26. oh man, you guys are retarded. Yes, it does sound like Holiday and Jessica admitted that her self by saying it has the same vibe. Where do you think artist get their influences by? She grew up to Madonna as did I. Ms. Spears songs sound like Madonna's at times. You people are just jealous. I would like to hear you guys sing. The song is awesome. As far as the comment regarding jessica needing a butt lift and and a nose job, please... she wouldnt be voted Hollywood's hottest body if she needed a butt lift and i am pretty sure she would not have done the movie Dukes of Hazzard if she had anything saggy on her bottom half. People get a grip. It seems that the majority of people only bag on the hot blondes ex. Paris, Brit and Jessica etc. etc. Let go of your jealousy and your life will be a lot less stressfull... Jessica deserves a pat on the back. The song would get me moving. Man, why doesnt anyone ever Congratulate a star rather than always bagging on them.


Love you Jessica, song is awesome!!!!!

Posted at 6:01PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Anna

27. tme to pak your bags and head back to texas the simpsons are finished
bad songs bad everything

Posted at 6:03PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Melissa

28. Someone said, "Where's the talent?!" Since when is being a pop star about talent! Jessica falls into the top 5 worst singers EVER... J Lo, Ashanti, Britney, Paris, and Jessica. And btw, it's not like she's the one ripping anyone off cuz she couldn't write a song if her life depended on it!

Posted at 6:07PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by u so pretty u could be a singer!

29. jessica having no talen?

Have any of you heard her sing live? and i do mean LIVE no lip singing or anything like that... well if you have you would know that she can sing her heart out!! She actually has one of the best voice out of all of them....


peace b!@#$%^

Posted at 6:17PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Anna

30. Jessica is just a silly girl, has she ever worked hard in her life? She used Nick. She has no talent for singing and acting, in fact her singing is worse than Paris.

Posted at 6:52PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Patty

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments