Celebrity Feuds
Smith vs. Siegel -- Round 2

Kevin Smith & Joel SiegelFor a movie he didn't like, film critic Joel Siegel is sure helping "Clerks 2" gain some publicity ... though it's not necessarily good. According to Kevin Smith's MySpace blog and Page Six, Siegel made the unprofessional move of disruptively storming out of a press screening for the new film. Both critic and filmmaker were on CBS Radio's "Opie and Anthony Show" this morning and the fight raged on.

"There's no reason I wanted to listen to anymore of it, I stood up and got a little carried away," Siegel said of his reaction to the film. The critic continued to defend himself on the radio show, apparently not realizing that he was talking to the director himself until 10 minutes into the tirade.

Smith refused to back down though saying, "You're a paid professional,sir, it's your job to sit there and watch a movie and review it, that's what you get paid for. It's one thing to walk out and if you don't want to do your job, fine, I understand the movie's not your cup of tea."

Siegel did note that he told Page Six he thought Kevin Smith was a very good filmmaker and he thought the original "Clerks" was one of the most important films of all time, something the gossip page forgot to mention. He also made a semi-apology, "If you'd like an apology, I'm glad to apologize. This was indeed the first movie I've walked out on in 30 years. If there's a second movie I walk out on, I'll be much quieter."

The film opens this Friday.

Listen to Smith & Siegel on CBS Radio



Filed under: Movies, Celebrity Feuds

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 3) | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. WHO CARES!??

the first movie was terrible.

Posted at 3:26PM on Jul 19th 2006 by downtowngirl

2. Kevin Smith you rock Joel Siegle is an old ,closed minded, little man, who obviously has past his time as a critic!!!

Posted at 3:36PM on Jul 19th 2006 by Melissa

3. Oh, that interview is too great. Go Kevin.

Posted at 3:39PM on Jul 19th 2006 by Kimberly

4. Joel Siegel is about as cool as a math test.

Posted at 4:04PM on Jul 19th 2006 by Kim

5. Kevin Smith is wayyyyyyyyy overated.

Posted at 4:17PM on Jul 19th 2006 by CANDY

6. Poor Joe Siegel, he is so OLD! Doesn't he know that Donkey shows are the "in" thing right now? Didn't he see Paris' new Donkey Video? Where she repeatedly tells the donkey he is poor, and waves a Carl's Jr. Hamburger in its face while she takes her clothes off, it is soo freakin HAWT!!!

I love Paris and TMZ foreverz!!!!!

Posted at 4:20PM on Jul 19th 2006 by yasodic

7. Joe Siegel should know better. This critic wants the public to take him seriously and then he pulls something like that. I mean one person might say who cares. That's true; but remember these critics give the public information and some people take this information seriously. A few years back I didn't go see a movie because the review was bad. When the video came out I saw it and enjoyed it, needless to say I never went by what a critic says. But some people do.

Posted at 5:00PM on Jul 19th 2006 by gwen

8. The writer of the article should know better: there is no such thing as "bad publicity".

And Smith has it right: a bad review from Siegel should be taken as a badge of honor.

And it's obvious 'downtowngirl' should go back downtown. The first movie was brilliant. I realize you probably had some difficulty with all of the dialogue and so many big words. Don't worry though, there's plenty of other movies out there that don't require much thought.

Posted at 5:02PM on Jul 19th 2006 by Dave

9. They're both acting like little bitches.

Posted at 7:21PM on Jul 19th 2006 by EO

10. Joel Siegel blows goats.

We have proof.

Posted at 1:11AM on Jul 20th 2006 by Rey

11. Did Siegel not see Clerks I?

Posted at 9:23AM on Jul 20th 2006 by Cookie Guggleman

12. I agree that Joe should not have made a scene when he walked out. He should have just waited to trash/critique the movie in print. However, there are times while watching a movie that makes one wonder why on Earth would anyone make such a film. There are so many movies out there that cater to the lowest common denominator. I have tried to sit through many and felt that if I stayed any longer I would actually be killing brain cells. This will work out great for Smith however. Any publicity is good publicity.

Posted at 9:57AM on Jul 20th 2006 by Sue

13. Also, I agree with the first post.

Posted at 9:58AM on Jul 20th 2006 by Sue

14. What I don't understand, is why they have old guys rating more 'teenage' ratings. It's ridiculous. Why don't they get smart, 'young' people to rate movies aimed at thier age group?

"Noobie" behavior wins. XD

Posted at 12:27PM on Jul 20th 2006 by Marquis

15. Kevin Smith is amazing.

Posted at 12:41PM on Jul 20th 2006 by Ladi Loera

| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Hot Tips

Email Alerts