Celebrity Feuds
Bad "Dog Whisperer"?

World-renowned dog trainer Cesar Millan is taking some serious heat for methods used on his hit show "Dog Whisperer." The American Humane Association recently deemed some of Millan's techniques "inhumane, outdated and improper." Now, as the show gets ready to launch its third season, TMZ has learned that the widely respected organization tried to get the show pulled from the air.

The group claims they were forced to take action after witnessing "numerous inhumane training techniques" on the show, including one instance where they claim a dog was partially asphyxiated after it was pinned to the ground by its neck. "We wanted National Geographic to pull the show" Bill Torgerson, Vice President of Animal Protection Services for American Humane Association, tells TMZ.

But the National Geographic Channel stands behind their star, claming that owners of several of the allegedly "abused" animals contacted them and praised Cesar for his work. When contacted by TMZ, the channel pointed out that the show has received a seal of approval from multiple respected professionals and animal organizations.


TMZ has learned that as a result of the AHA's concern, the show will now feature a cautionary statement to remind viewers "There are many methods of dog training and owners should work with professionals to choose the right approach for them."

Torgerson tells TMZ that they are still working closely with the network on "eliminating the broadcasting of certain techniques" but they've stopped their push to pull the show entirely.

Season three of "Dog Whisperer" debuts Monday on the National Geographic Channel.

Filed under: TV, Celebrity Feuds

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 6) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. OMG, I have watched his show over and over, I cry BS to you inhumane idiots. He is very good and has proven to be good. He takes animals that would be killed or put to sleep because they are not fit for humans and / or have been severaly abused and turns then around. You flipping animal righteous idiots should shut up and look at what he does for the animals. I LOVE LOVE animals so dont get any inhumane ideas about me.

Posted at 5:47PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Dolly

2. Ridiculous! I am an avid dog lover, member of PETA and the Humane Society of America and I am Cesar's biggest fan--his techniques are not cruel and no dog has ever been "pinned to the ground by it's neck"--there are episodes where dog fights have occurred and Cesar was forced to separate 2 dogs and hold one by it's neck scruff-as a mother dog would-his techniques are the techniques of dogs themselves--if he is cruel so are other dogs--come on people--focus on real cruelty dealers like circuses and greyhound racing and factory farming! Cesar has taken in countless dogs that would have been euthanized by ignorant and fearful humans and given them happy lives--if that is cruel then he deserves an award for it!

Posted at 5:51PM on Oct 20th 2006 by LilyOberon

3. why don't theese people go find some actual animal abusers and leave the guy who has helped so many people alone...

Posted at 5:51PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Audi

4. That is such crap! Cesar Millan is awesome! He really understands dogs, and he has helped thousands! He doesn't abuse dogs! That is ridiculous! I don't know what dog they were talking about (the one that was being allegedly choked)... maybe it was the Korean Jindo, but that dog was vicious! Cesar was just trying to dominate him. Oy! Dumb ppl!

Posted at 5:56PM on Oct 20th 2006 by sontzi

5. I was taking a loose dog back home today when the neighbor's bulldog attacked. I used Ceasar's "shhhh" and a firm tone, and the dog backed away. The bulldog's owner was amazed, and wanted to know where I learned that. The Dog Whisper. No physical touch, no yelling or screaming. Please, humane society, use the money to stop puppy mills, or to help spay and nueter. Leave Ceasar be.

Posted at 6:12PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Anna Malik-Turyn

6. I work with a dog rescue organization, and Milan's tips have always been both humane and helpful. This sounds like more petulant PETA B.S. to me, and I would urge NG to ignore it

Posted at 6:29PM on Oct 20th 2006 by tw111

7. My daughter and her dog (Emily, the Pitbull) were featured on Dog Whisperer. It was the best thing that ever happened for Emily. Ceaser showed my daughter training techniques, and made very helpful suggestions. I don't believe that Emily would be the happy dog she is today had it not been for Mr. Milan.

Posted at 6:34PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Cherry Poppens

8. What in the name of all that is righteousand holy is this country coming to? First you can't say bad things about certain "sensitive" ethnic groups, you can't tell certain jokes if women around, no more making fun of "mentally challenged" people NOW THIS! Golly Miss Molly: No fun allowed, anywhere. Grabbing a stupid, vicious dog by his neck and holding him down is almost as much fun as tying tin cans to a cats tail, or setting a rat on fire and watching it run in circles. Where does it end, where I ask you??? We love you Ceasar! Support your local "No kill Shelter!"

Posted at 6:44PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Barbara Woodhouse did it better, and first!

9. I know the Humane Societies do great things for animals, but so does Cesar. They're using Cesar for publicity for their cause, instead of realizing they all have the same agenda. They need to worry more about truly inhumane actions by people.

Posted at 6:45PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Stormy

10. I DO RESCUE AND CESAR IS A GREAT PERSON FOR WHAT HE DOES. THESE POOR ANIMALS WOULD BE DEAD IF IT WASN'T FOR HIM. GO FIND A PUPPY MILL AND TAKE CARE OF STUFF THAT REALLY NEEDS YOUR ATTENTION!!!!

Posted at 7:09PM on Oct 20th 2006 by kris

11. I am an avid Cesar Millan fan and have even been to his seminars to hear him speak. This man loves all animals and especially dogs. For anyone to even hint at the fact that he mistreats dogs is absolutely absurd. This man knows what he's doing and case after case we have seen his success. Leave the one man who is actually getting through to people and helping Dogs to get rehabilitaed alone.

Posted at 7:11PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Wendy

12. American Humane is NOT the SPCA or animal shelters or the Humane Society or peta

It is one SEPARATE group, and to be honest they havn't done too much for animals

Please, folks, don't gt the different groups confused!!

Posted at 7:14PM on Oct 20th 2006 by kelly

13. Ceasar is awesome. I have been on the receiving of of some local trainers who bristle at the mention of his name - it is mainly because he is making it a little harder for them to make a living...ah yes, jealousy be thy name.

Posted at 7:33PM on Oct 20th 2006 by danielle

14. WE LOVE YOU CESAR! Keep up the good work!

Posted at 7:34PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Stormy

15. This guy is so overrated. I luv dog trainer Matthew Margolis "Uncle Matty." He is humane and kind with a terrific understanding of animals.

Posted at 7:36PM on Oct 20th 2006 by Pieta

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Hot Tips