"Lost" Diary -- The Constant

LostHey, it's Daniel here, back with another edition of the "Lost" Diary.

To battle through the doldrums of the week, several TMZ staffers compete in a weekly tournament of a game we invented called Dartball. I had never won a Dartball tournament until February 1 -- the day after "Lost" premiered. I have now won four in a row, meaning I am undefeated for as long as "Lost" has been on this year. Coincidence?

For all you "Lost" Diary newbies, here's how it goes: I gather with a group of friends watching "Lost," writing what happens on the show as it happens, and throwing in my two cents along the way. I am watching tonight's episode of "Lost" alone as Ari and Lauren had plans, and I had to bail on my friend Stacy because my car wouldn't start after my basketball game tonight, so it's currently sitting outside a 76 gas station on Santa Monica Blvd. Good times. Let's roll ...

9:00 -- Whoa, no previously on "'Lost'" -- that's weird.

9:02 -- It's Desmond flashback time (you can tell by the hair). It's interesting to see we're back to doing flashbacks again.

9:03 -- Wait, Desmond is dreaming about being on the island? Um ...

9:04 -- "Who are you? How do you know my name?" -- Desmond

9:08 -- "Your perception of how long your friends have been gone, it's not necessarily how long they've actually been gone." -- Faraday. How could Jack not press him more on this?

9:10 -- Desmond is clearly suffering from the "side effects" that Faraday spoke of.

9:11 -- Great, are we in for another trippy Desmond flashback? I don't think my brain can handle it.

9:12 -- Desmond is back in the military and having flashes about being on the boat -- which he is currently on. Does anybody have any Advil?

9:13 -- Now he's back on the freighter. Side note: tonight's episode was written by Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse -- so you know it's going to be a doozy.

9:14 -- "It's happening to you too, isn't it?" -- guy who looks like Tom Hanks in "Philadelphia" but towards the end when it got really bad.

9:18 -- Could you imagine if it were Sayid that went nuts? They'd all be screwed.

9:19 -- Sayid finally calls Jack on the phone, tells everyone Desmond's "condition" and now Faraday is explaining that people can get "confused" going to and from the island. Am I going to need my scientific calculator for this episode?

9:20 -- Desmond's new friend was "just on a ferris wheel."

9:22 -- Back in the Army again, Desmond is calling Penny and she wants nothing to do with him.

9:23 -- Sayid and the Lawnmower man break into the sick bay so that Desmond can talk to Faraday -- and the doc rang the alarm. Causing a ruckus on the boat is not a good idea. Just a guess.

9:24 -- Desmond thinks it's 1996. I was a freshman in college that year, so if it were 1996 I would be totally fine with that.

9:25 -- Faraday just instructed Desmond to, in 1996 mind you, come and find him. After 25 minutes, this episode is an A for sure. WTF is going on? Although, what Desmond is going through does suggest why Faraday is on the mission in the first place.

9:29 -- Faraday is giving Desmond things to say to his past himself so he will believe him when he finds him. More Advil, please.

9:31 -- 1996 Desmond has found 1996 Daniel Faraday and spit back to him all the things he was supposed to say. If anyone is curious, "Back to the Future II" is on HBO on 3/8 at 12:30 PM ET. Just saying ...

9:33 -- Faraday's lab is only like a 5 on the Creepy Lab scale.

9:35 -- Faraday's rat experiment is somehow linked to what is going on with Desmond, since Faraday's rat just ran a maze he hasn't learned how to run yet.

9:37 -- So Tom Hanks in "Philadelphia" guy is Minkowski, the Communications Officer, who tells Desmond that Penelope has been calling the boat. I am starting to realize that I will be of no help as this episode goes on -- I can only ride it as best I can and hope to make some sense of it when it is over.

9:44 -- After a lot of explaining, and some science and what have you, Faraday basically tells Desmond to find Penelope. Did Desmond really need him for that?

9:45 -- Desmond and Sayid are going to break into the communications room, with Minkowski, to call Penny.

9:46 -- "Looks like you guys have a friend on this boat." -- Minkowski. Michael, perhaps?

9:47 -- A journal belonging to the first mate aboard the Black Rock, which was lost at sea, is up for auction. Really? On top of all that I am trying to figure out here you throw the Black Rock at me too? Come on!!! And it belonged to Tovard Hanso!!! Seriously? I can't handle this anymore!!! Make it stop!!! And it's lot 2342!!! Why can't I stop using exclamation marks!!!???

9:48 -- And Penny's dad just bought it.

9:49 -- Penny's dad is back to belittling Desmond, and I kinda find it funny.

9:50 -- I wonder who Penny is with in 1996?

9:51 -- Minkowski is out like a light, bleeding from the nose and grunting, "I can't get back." Not a pretty picture for Desmond, is it?

9:52 --- RIP Minkowski.

9:55 -- 1996 Desmond is out like a light on the floor of a bathroom. It sure seems like the point of this episode is for 1996 Desmond to find 1996 Penny -- but what will he really find when he does? Or better yet, who?

9:56 -- 1996 Desmond is begging 1996 Penny for her number so 2004 Desmond can call 2004 Penny. Easily the most ridiculous sentence I have ever written.

9:57 -- 1996 Desmond just told 1996 Penny that he will call her on December 24, 2004. No joke -- the hairs on the back of my neck just stood up.

9:58 -- Ring, ring, ring, ring, ring ...

9:59 -- "Penny?" -- Desmond

10:00 -- If you're not choked up right now, I'm sorry -- we can't ever be friends.

10:01 -- "If anything goes wrong, Desmond Hume will be my constant." -- Faraday's journal

Let's get the easy stuff out of the way. This episode gets an A+. It was one of the pantheon, other level, top notch "Lost" episodes of all-time. I will be floored if I get even one email or IM from a friend of mine who didn't flat out love it.

But that's not what this is about. I could sit here and try to decipher what went down in tonight's episode -- and I would fail miserably. I don't think I could come up with any theory that will help explain any of this. I'll leave that to you guys on the message boards.

What this episode is really about is television. If I've said it once, I've said it a million times -- I look down on people who look down on television. In the last year, have any of you seen a movie that topped tonight's episode? "No Country for Old Men" or "The Constant" -- what would you rather watch? Not even close, is it?

Tonight's episode of "Lost" was great, and it reminded me why I love the show -- but more than that it reaffirmed my love of television. It reminded me why I invest years of my life in certain shows. Anyone can sit in a theater for two hours, that's easy. Television is work and "Lost" is the kind of job that makes your wife leave you because you're always at the office and you never have time for her.

But it's all worth it, right?

I choked up at the end of this episode just like everyone who has a pulse who watched tonight's show did. But I'll be honest with you -- I am kind of choked up again right now when I think about the power of television. I always say that my dream job is to be a television critic, but I don't want to call it that. I am a television advocate -- and right now, at this exact moment as I write this (11:43 PM PT) I am reminded again of why.

You and I are going to spend the bulk of our Friday reading and posting comments on this site and asking everyone we know that watches the show, "Oh my God, did you see 'Lost' last night?"

Let's see the movies do that.

Over at thelostdiary.com, I do a question-and-answer column every week. I imagine this week will be good, since I have plenty to discuss this week. But don't feel like you have to ask a straightforward "Lost" question. Have fun with it. Click here to send me a question.

Reader Comments

(Page 22 of 22) Previous 15 Comments

316. It makes no sense YET!!!

Posted at 10:02PM on Mar 2nd 2008 by I'llTake Sawyer

317. There was a great article in today's Boston Globe Arts section about how the "flash forward," as used in shows like Lost, is a new construct and changing the face of television. It gave me renewed faith that the writers have a grand plan and this flows from a bold vision that is not -- repeat, IS NOT -- being made up as they go along....

Posted at 10:39PM on Mar 2nd 2008 by Sinead

318. I know that overanalysis can ruin anything, but I need some insight, so if anyone can clarify I'll let it go, promise.

If it's not really timetravel in the traditional sense, and Desmond is travelling only in his mind, how is it that he is affecting and enacting? He's transporting information (the numbers to Daniel, Penny's phone number). Am I being thick? Very possible, so any help is welcome!

Posted at 11:03PM on Mar 2nd 2008 by Sinead

319. Can we all stop OVER-USING the term "jumping the shark"? Come on peolpe! We watch one of the smartest shows ever and you continue to be uninventive!!!

Posted at 11:13PM on Mar 2nd 2008 by Nauti girl

320. Oh man! I can't even wrap my brain around a comment I just read- "Ben has mastered bouncing between realities"! That explains how he knows so much about each passenger on the flight! I flip-flapping love this damn show!! It is sooooo intriguing!!!!!

Posted at 11:18PM on Mar 2nd 2008 by Nauti girl

321. Kudos for Daniel's kudos to TV over movies. My local television critic, Tim Goodman of the San Francisco Chronicle, who I bet is one of Daniel's favorite television critics, wrote a terrific article on February 22 titled "TV is Better Than Movies" -- but goes on to add "except this year." Interesting read, and not totally off the mark: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2008/02/22/DDB1V61HM.DTL

By the way, my wife and I just watched this episode and we were indeed choked up.

Posted at 12:08AM on Mar 3rd 2008 by Allen

322. I am a little baffled that most people loved this episode so much......I think it almost ruins the show.......C'mon, we're time travelling now?........If 1996 Desmond found out this stuff, wouldn't he just stay off the boat......therefore, never been on the Island????.......Episode was dumb dumb dumb

Posted at 12:56AM on Mar 3rd 2008 by poppa

323. Response to #127 (Kelly) - I thinkg there might be something to the "parallel universe" theory - I had all kinds of great thoughts to add when i read your comments, but am too tired now to explain. Just a couple of random thoughts:

1, Two episodes ago - when Kate was on trial - Jack is on the stand and first says they crashed on the island but just moments later says they crashed in the ocean. I think that is significant since there have been scenes of the plane at the bottom of the ocean with no survivors, yet we know that 8 people "left" the island.

2. Why do some think Michael is on the boat when he was just on the island getting Locke out of the pit after being shot by Ben.

3. Does anyone know what is the significance. of Hurley seeing Charlie in the future (when he is again in the asylum). Is it an hallucination,? did Charlie not die? Is he part of the "parallel universe" theory?

4. I thinkg Aaron has real significance in the future and Kate knows it. For some reason Claire was not able to leave the island so Kate agrees to take Aaron for the sake of his meaning in the future. In the future, Jack knows of Aaron's significance but he was unable to help bring his 1/2 sis - and Aaron's mother back with them so he feels to much guilt about it.

This show makes me soo crazy - i am addicted and will need re-hab when it ends.

G'nite all.

p.s. - When Sawyer flipped Kate in the bed in the "eggtown" Ep - OMG the sexiest thing ever!!!!

Posted at 2:41AM on Mar 3rd 2008 by lorigirl

324. Great, obivously. Um, a little "The Time Travelor's Wife"? Just a bit? Can't wait to see how this whole thing plays out. I was just a tad high when I watched it the first time which made it a million times more random, but also made me a million times more perceptive. Watched it again later--still confused, not as perceptive. Huh.

One question, if time goes faster on the island (the chopper ride only took 20 mins, about, and Jack and all them thought it had been a day and a half) then it wouldn't have been as long in "real life" as it has been on the island. Meaning, it would be less than 90 days since the plane crashed. So, the theory that more time has passed in "real life" does not seem to hold. Right? So how did "the lawnmower man" end up going from potential 815 pilot to surf bum in 90 days or less? It seems, according to the calendar, that time on and off the island are the same...so I am a little lost, and can someone please show me how this works without there being story inconsistencies?? Did they put up a fake calendar? But it was Christmas eve for Penny...??? Is it just perception only? Is that why Hurley hasn't lost any weight? What about the clocks though that daniel had--two different times.

Posted at 12:27PM on Mar 3rd 2008 by me

325. Great Episode. btw, Minkowski was played by Fisher Stevens, who was in several movies (Short Circuit) and dated Michelle Pfieffer in the 80s.

Posted at 2:32PM on Mar 5th 2008 by dave

326. is minkowski the guy that gave hurley the numbers in the mental institution?

Posted at 1:03PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Ashleigh

327. Ok. I love this show as much as anyone, but I was fairly disappointed in this episode... if the new theme get abused. I felt ala 'Back to the future' in this and I hope this is not used as a cop out for anything the writers feel it can be used for moving forward. I think it's great that Desmond can move through time. If Richard Alpert and Ben can too, that would be fine with me. I'll be mad if the court sequence with jack and Kate and the only 8 survivers' if it is used as bring real in an altenate reality. I do not want the show to get away from what it is. I also like it best when the focus is on the main characters. I love the mystery... the monster, the cabin, the 4 toed statue. I hope we don't veer to far from the beloved mysteries.... as long as it does not get too sci-fi, great. I am hopeful....
Here is another question, where are the others? In a cave somewhere?
And yes, I feel that maybe Michael is on the boat.

Posted at 1:20PM on Mar 6th 2008 by kre

Previous 15 Comments