1. Big whoop.

Posted at 2:56PM on Mar 5th 2008 by the jerk

2. wasnt there a movie called cruising back in hte late 70s..about gay men picking up dudes...anyway whateva

Posted at 3:01PM on Mar 5th 2008 by nuff_said

3. OK, so they threw off a girl a few years ago over nude photos (that if I recall correctly, were intended to be private, and some jerk leaked them), but a guy who strips in gay bars and gives men lap dances gets to stay and it's all just dandy. Double standard much?

Posted at 3:28PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Seanette

4. Leave this guy alone - who gives a s**** what kind of jobs he has had? So what!
I know plenty of straight guys (and girls) that work at gay bars, and even strip.
Sometimes you guys are a little to judgemental!

Posted at 3:42PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Stevo

5. Whoa, David is old enough to work in a strip join? Does he have a hot bod? And I thought professional musicians couldn't compete on Idol... doesn't this count as a professional gig?

Come to think of it... aren't a lot of the contestants technically pros too? (pro singers, not the other thing)

Posted at 3:42PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Federico "Fred" Malek

6. Contestants can compete on AI as long as they don't have a record deal. And, I highly doubt these 4 released any vinyl.

Posted at 4:05PM on Mar 5th 2008 by RealityTVHo

7. Who the heck is the lead singer in this group? You can't even tell! It looks like they are singing something different and was voiced over.

Posted at 4:47PM on Mar 5th 2008 by udontknowme

8. We need a video of him stripping. Wonder if he was good at it or not. Maybe he can work that into one of his up and coming Idol routines? EH?

Posted at 5:02PM on Mar 5th 2008 by SuperStarSteve

9. Ewwwww, ish.

Posted at 5:14PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Lulabelle

10. David H is Hot! No Double Standard. On a previous AI season, finalist Nikki worked as a stripper to support herself and daughter. She wasn't kicked off. Frenchie was on a porn website. Big difference. However, the Vinyl Four guy singing next to David IS on a gay porn website showing his all, front and back under "Ryan Seacrest", oops, "Ryan Steele".

Posted at 5:24PM on Mar 5th 2008 by plaintruthiness

11. I don't know what's worse. David Hernandez or someone being classless enough to actually record a cruise ship performance.

Posted at 5:56PM on Mar 5th 2008 by joe

12. HMM, TMZ on Fox
American Idol on Fox,
Idol not doing well,
TMZ reports on these Idol nobodies daily

is this working Fox?

Posted at 6:38PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Lock

13. Why can't Idol be what it is supposed to be--a platform for people who have never been discovered? It seems this gent was at least a semi-pro and that just seems unfair to the spirit of the rank amature giving it a go at the big time. And besides, their rules are their rules and they should be enforced equally--Frenchie was booted for racy behavior; to not give das same boot to David would be a serious show of discrimination.

Posted at 8:02PM on Mar 5th 2008 by wasted days and wasted nights

14. The guys on this are strippers too:::::
WANTS to see his boyfriend in action??. Believe me he was in dirtyboyvideo com, and here is the link to the caps:

[queerclick c!o!m /archive /2008 /03 /david_hernandezs_two_degrees_separation]


add .php to last and format with removing spaces and com with . part.

Posted at 9:43PM on Mar 5th 2008 by TrueTeller

15. Wow! the performance sure brought tears to my eyes,to me there is nothiing like singing acapella,it was more then touching,it brought some memories back,good ones, The guys in the groupe should make the 4 of them in to there own Acapella band,Thanks so much for making my day,Love you guys

Posted at 10:36PM on Mar 5th 2008 by Kim Phelan