Navarro vs. McLean: Who'd You Rather?!

first

Is DAve wearing lip liner? GROSS!!!

Kooky is a bum.

neither one - look like old perverts

wow! i love AJ.....and dave's not to badd either.....
but.....
they both look horriblw in these pics!!!!

Nice Jackie-O shades. They should win the award for weird beards.

Dave looks like Willy Wonka (Johnny Depp with the wig).

AJ ALL THE WAY!! HE IS SO HOT!!

TMZ...WHEN ARE YOU GOING TO GET IT.. PLEASE ADD NEITHER!!!

Ugghhh.. and icky gross.. Dave looks like Seth from the Fly!! He is a greasy little shrimp! I heard him on Howard Stern that he eats his own you know what! Very Very Disgusting

Dang, Now yo have the readers choosing between drug addicts.Hi-Five WTG

NOTICE HOW TMZ ALWAYS FORGET TO INCLUDE THE "NONE OF THE ABOVE" OPTION. YOU ALL KNOW THAT GETS THE MAJORITY VOTE!!! JUST SAYIN.

Id rather just...not.

navarro used to be hot before he started acting all weird and disgustingly LA...I remember when he was in Janes all strung out. He was not as attractive because he was junkie skinny but at least he could write guitar solos.

Now they do theme songs for TV cable shows.

Alex (A.j) got my vote HOTTEST MAN OF THE YEAR so ofcourse he'll be the one i rather....... XD

Yea one can play guitar and has been in actual you know bands that play music the the other can eat, lip sync and be a d-bag other than that quite similar.