TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Duff vs. Duff

Who'd You Rather?

7/3/2010 4:25 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

Biological sisters Haylie Duff, 25, and Hilary Duff, 22, resurfaced at the same event in NYC on Thursday.

0702_DUFF_102574848
Question is ... 


27 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

Jubuti    

I like Hilary, but the guys she dates (like hockey players) she probably has like the stretched bloodseed by now. She's still is cute though.

1387 days ago
2.

Irene    

Haylie would look so much better with bangs..her forehead is so long it makes her face look too long and then she poofs the center of her hair to make it worse. She could be a beautiful girl.

1387 days ago
3.

Truth    

QUESTION OF THE CENTURY: WHY IS "NONE OF THE ABOVE" NEVER AN ANSWER, LEVIN??

1387 days ago
4.

truth hurts    

Both are refreshingly beautiful...I'm so sick of the fake hollywood T and A... These are real women and they look great!

1387 days ago
5.

fredsdead    

Neither.
One has a bad nose job and the other has a awful set of veneers.
Bad veneers = bad breath.

1387 days ago
6.

valerie    

If Hailey is plumping her lips, she needs to stop now. She is beautiful uniquely and should stay that way. Don't be a loser and suc***b to Hollyweird standards. Those are some damn looowww standards btw.

1387 days ago
7.

valerie    

That bleeped out work was suc comb ed...lol, silly auto filter thingy.

1387 days ago
8.

Criss    

When did Haylie start resembling a shoe?

1387 days ago
9.

Chia    

Neither

1387 days ago
10.

Brian    

Haylie looks like Sarah Jessica Parker when her horse face was just a pony.

1387 days ago
11.

mike    

What's wrong with Haylie's Head?????

1387 days ago
12.

omgsammi    

wow, i would hate to be haylie, the ugly, older, not famous sister..

1387 days ago
13.

Phreaky    

NEIGHHHHHHHHther one.

1387 days ago
14.

lobbi    

Haylie's nose is just 2 big, sorry. Her head is shaped like a pickle, plus how do U get 2 her lips if a guy wants 2 give her a kiss when that big fat nose is in the way? She's not as pretty as her younger sister, Hilary, whose features R better proportionate 2 her head.

1387 days ago
15.

Kell    

Isn't Hailey her mother?

1387 days ago
| 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web