TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Nicole vs. Cheryl

Who'd You Rather?

5/26/2011 4:30 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Former Pussycat Dolls lead singer Nicole Scherzinger, 32, just replaced former Girls Aloud member Cheryl Cole, 27, on the U.S. version of "The X Factor."

0526_nicole_cheryl

Question is ...

132 COMMENTS

No Avatar
61.

dany    

people who are happy cheryl cole is out ,havent seen her on x factor uk..cause if they would have they would know that cheryl brings alot to the show,and drama seems to always follow her wich makes for great tv...

1155 days ago
62.

Alexa    

Don't know why women flash their phony looking boobs..not natural looking or attractive at all, Nicole! Ewwww!

1155 days ago
63.

Jack    

I remember back when Nicole was still in Louisville. Doing drugs and hanging out with Travis Meeks. Sleeping with whoever she could to get to the top... I guess it kind of worked. But please lay off the plastic surgery... Oh and please stop singing... Its just awful...

1155 days ago
64.

Ivanhoe    

Cheryl Cole's abit new, but she's growing on me alot. She's stunning and her best song is definatly Parachute.

1155 days ago
65.

Roxy    

I really love Nicole but I don't really think she's got a big personality, not very watchable. Do want to know more about Cheryl and I understand her fine and I'm from Chicago. Pictures horrible sorry Nicole I know your sexy!!!

1155 days ago
66.

vanessa    

Nicole is the best...We need more exotic women

1155 days ago
67.

Sarah Cribble    

I'm sorry but with Nicole the show will be such a bellyflop. I mean Nicole and Paula. Please. I was really happy that over here we were finally getting to know some british talent (ellie goulding on snl and adele being successful) but i was most looking forward to cheryl and now that isnt going to happen i'm not going to watch. nicole is f*ck ugly and has a sh*t solo career

1155 days ago
68.

Gibbo    

STUPID!!!! Cheryl actually rules. She's so hot. Nicole was **** on UK X Factor and her performance of lead single Poison was so dreary, plus it flopped.

1155 days ago
69.

yordi    

Oh maybe they know about her assult to that poor women & she has a problem with black people:P

1155 days ago
70.

Louise    

This story of her departure from US X Factor still needs to be confirmed, but fans of US X Factor need to understand, there is a reason this woman is so massively unpopular in her own country.

The viewers in the UK took her to their hearts initially, and many even forgave her for her criminal behaviour in attacking the toilet attendant and racial remarks she made against her.

The love affair with Cheryl unravelled big time, when the true character and personality and lack of talent became obvious, when watching her over a period of time as judge on UK X Factor.
Compared to other judges such as Danni Minogue, she was one dimensional, boring and brought nothing to the show.


Simon Cowell has good business sense, but this infatuation with CC, and his massive support for her in the US, just seems incomprehensible to many people.
She is a one trick pony, riding on her looks alone, which at the end of the day, can only take a person so far.

Nicole at least, brings to the judging table a greater maturity, more engaging personality, the ability to string an articulate sentence together, and as Simon would say - "the likeability factor".

1155 days ago
71.

msfanni    

Neiter would be a good option here.

1155 days ago
72.

Brieonna    

I LOVE cheryl and was supposed to go see a live taping soon NOT ANYMORE..not even like nicole is a star here , she only does well in Europe..

1155 days ago
73.

hlen    

NICOLE NICOLE NICOLE NICOLE
who THE HELL even is cheryl cole?

1155 days ago
74.

kiara    

i selfishly want her to be sacked so she comes back to uk xfactor...

1155 days ago
75.

Jen    

Nicole, Cherly is nothing but a talentless racist. When we saw Nicole on the UK X-Factor she seemed very genuine and likable. Cherly is very fake and most of the time looks bored.

Cheryl is a gorgeous woman, as is Nicole but has very little talent. Watch her auction for Popstars on youtube to see her sing! Its much worse than so many people she says are terrible!

1155 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web