TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Amanda Knox vs. Casey Anthony

Who'd You Rather?

10/3/2011 1:00 PM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

1003_whodrather
Amanda Knox was just found not guilty of the murder of her college roommate, while Casey Anthony was acquitted for the murder of her daughter earlier this year.

Question is ...


More Who'd You Rather?

223 COMMENTS

No Avatar
61.

TMZ Is Destined To Be The Next News of The World    

Ew, neither. And it's not bc they may or may not have killed another human being.

1083 days ago
62.

Rico Suavy    

I would let Amanda p--s on one eye if I could keep the other one open. I would let Casey sit on my face. Just trying to add some intelligent input to the poll.

1083 days ago
63.

CriticXtreme    

I smell reality show!

1083 days ago
64.

BR415    

A truly inappropriate comparison. Can you guys show a little mercy and compassion for Amanda Knox and her family? This girl didn't do anything to deserve to be in the public's eye at all. What reason do you have for sensationalizing her by comparing her to Casey Anthony?

Meredeith Kercher's murder destroyed the lives of three young, promising, innocent individuals. They and their families have been victims of a terrible crime and terrible treatment by the media and the Italian judicial system. Give them some peace and leave them alone.

1083 days ago
65.

PushBack    

Poor taste TMZ. What are you thinking?

1083 days ago
66.

jilly    

stop comparing the two.

1083 days ago
67.

Rogue Warrior    

What up all you emotionally illiterate, Nancy Disgrace following, irrational, rode wet, mental midgets? NOT GUILTY, NOT GUILTY, NOT GUILTY!

1083 days ago
68.

Lola    

Amanda is attractive, while Casey Anthony is not. Amanda is intelligent, was in college in Italy, while Casey Anthony dropped out of high school and never got her diploma. One of them is a higher quality, more intelligent person. Casey Anthony is guilty of murdering her own child. I didn't follow the Amanda case too closely, but the cir****tances don't point to her guilt so clearly as cir****tances point to Casey Anthony's guilt. Casey Anthony is said to be the most hated person in America, while I think Amanda Knox will be welcomed back home.

1083 days ago
69.

Charlie Sheen's Watch    

Oh man, I would pound Amanda like a champ! Imagine this girl - she is going to come out of that jail like a bitch in heat - she will want to bang anything and everything that looks like a penis.

This girl looks like she has some good punany! I mean really.....hot!!!!

1083 days ago
70.

TMZISAPIECEOFSHIT    

There are two people brutally murdered surrounding these two accused murderers and all we want to discuss is who would you rather screw?

America is getting dumber by the day.

1083 days ago
71.

media_lush    

the TMZ editor who dreamed up this little stunt should be ashamed of him/herself.... just sick and pathetic

1083 days ago
72.

Linda    

Amanda has a loving supportive family. Casey was brought up in a dysfunctional psycho environment. So there really is no choice here. Also, Amanda did not have a Nancy Grace coverage that completely biased people to hate here like Casey had.

1083 days ago
73.

RaisinCain    

Stay classy TMZ. Piece of **** website. Disgusting.

1083 days ago
74.

JLRN    

Tacky TMZ.. Really

1083 days ago
75.

makeitstop    

this is really sick Harvey

1083 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web