Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Oscar Pistorius

You Be the Judge

2/23/2013 2:15 PM PST BY TMZ STAFF

Oscar Pistorius is a free man while his case winds through the legal system of South Africa. Did he get special treatment, and did he murder Reeva Steenkamp? We gotta ask ...

Did he murder Reeva?

  • Yes
  • No

Intruder defense

  • I believe it
  • BS

Oscar gets bail

  • Appropriate
  • Outrageous

Oscar will flee

  • Yes
  • No

Athletes are prone to violence

  • Yes
  • No

More violent

  • Athletes
  • Rappers

More violent

  • Oscar
  • Chris Brown

He'll be found guilty

  • Yes
  • No

Is Oscar getting celebrity justice?

  • Yes
  • No

For more sports stories, check out tmzsports.com!

No Avatar

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5


Facts and Evidence Support the Following:
After lengthy argument, likely ending up in bathroom,
Pist strikes Reeva's phone from her grasp; She escapes to toilet closet and
locks door.
Pist trots to bedroom, gathers gun; returns to 'hearing sounds' of Reeva flushing or urinating into toilet; fires 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th bullets diagonally, targeting 2-3 feet above toilet seat, to strike Reeva’s head/ upper body, until her screaming stops.
A well-conceived, perfectly executed, execution.. demonstrating
considerable planning and specific intent in those final moments.. including the
one and only scenario which provides the "excuse" of 'I couldn't see the person
I decided to shoot to death.'
Consider the probability that the person in the bathroom next to your bedroom at 3 AM is your bed mate who's not within your sight at the moment ? (I'd say, about 99.9999%)
And considering that the subject home is within a walled, gated, armed-guarded complex;
By the forensics, facts, Pist own affidavit, witnesses and Pist history of jealous aggression and violent threats, Pist killing of Ms. Steenkamp is likely one of the most well-do***ented cases of cold-blooded murder in history. It would take a buffoon to rule the killing to be an ‘accident’. We’ll see how corrupt/ incompetent SA can be.
I believe Pist crocodile tears are real - for himself.
He's very sorry that he 'f**ked up' HIS life.

419 days ago


The NRA will sponsor him if NIKE drops him.

419 days ago


Really TMZ... THAT is one of your in depth questions? "Do you think he's worse than Chris Brown?"

You people are idiots.

419 days ago


you shouldn't be encouraging people to judge when the information is still coming in. This is one of the big things wrong with the country, everyone coming to conclusions based on feelings but no information.

419 days ago


As an American who has lived in South Africa, I can say that most people who have not lived there or in a country plagued with extremely violent and deadly crime, will not understand how easily this type of accident could happen. Did he murder her? I don't know, that is for a judge to decide. But in a broad sense, his claim is extremely plausible.

419 days ago


Tired of tmz racist positions. Good point, who is more violent Oscar or Colorado shooter?

419 days ago


Oscar MURDERED his girl, yet Chris Brown (who i think is an a-hole) is voted more violent?........that seems odd

419 days ago


Is this some kind of anti-gun image? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't remember a shotgun or an AR15 rifle being involved in this murder.

418 days ago

en Todo Momento!!    

free the boers

418 days ago

John Elliott    

Says something when Chris Brown is considered more violent then a guy that kill his gf and smashes her head in with a cricket racquet. Kind of F up

418 days ago


come on people the poll at the top on number 7 doesn't ask which one you dislike more it asks who is more violent. Chris Brown punched Rihanna in the face and yet here she is dumb enough to be back with him meanwhile this other guy is being charged with murder, yet people still voted Chris as more violent. I guess its okay to kill someone but not punch them in the face. Both are wrong but just sayin.

418 days ago

Jericho Morton    

The story of Pi. Pi Storius. It is a series of circles within circles. Story "account of some happening," early 13c., "narrative of important events or celebrated persons of the past," from Old French estorie, from Late Latin storia and Latin historia "history, account, tale, story" (see history). Meaning "recital of true events" first recorded late 14c.; sense of "narrative of fictitious events meant to entertain" is from c.1500. Not differentiated from history till 1500s. As a euphemism for "a lie" it dates from 1690s. Meaning "newspaper article" is from 1892. Story-teller is from 1709. Story-line first attested 1941. That's another story "that requires different treatment" is attested from 1818. Story of my life "sad truth" first recorded 1938.

418 days ago


so cb is more dangerous than this guy? but this guy went all the way n killed someone. not understanding

418 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Around The Web