Melinda vs. Nikki: Who'd You Rather? Melinda vs. Nikki Who'd You Rather? 11/24/2009 4:27 PM PT Former "American Idol" wannabeen Melinda Doolittle and "Hairspray" star Nikki Blonsky glammed it up at the same event in NYC last night. Question is ... See Also Shakira vs. Sofia: Who'd You Rather?Liza vs. Arlene: Who'd You Rather? Share on Facebook Share on X Nikki Blonsky Melinda Doolittle Who'd You Rather?