Maksim vs. Evan vs. Tony Who'd You Rather?

11/2/2010 3:25 PM PDT

Maksim vs. Evan vs. Tony: Who'd You Rather?

While showing off their incredible tans -- dancers Maksim Chmerkovskiy, 30, Evan Lysacek, 25 and Tony Dovolani, 37, grinned for a photo while attending an after-party for "Dancing With the Stars."

The question is...