Julie vs. Tinsley vs. Kelly Who'd You Rather?

3/24/2011 6:30 AM PDT

Julie vs. Tinsley vs. Kelly: Who'd You Rather?

Former "Dexter" beauty Julie Benz, 38, socialite Tinsley Mortimer, 34,and "Real Housewives of NYC" enigma Kelly Killoren Bensimon, 42, all lounged around at the same event in NYC on Tuesday.

Question is ...