Stars and Scars -- You Be the Judge Stars and Scars You Be the Judge 5/2/2015 12:40 AM PT Rosie O'Donnell is in a nuclear war with her estranged wife over their kid, while Sofia Vergara is fighting her ex-fiance over having a kid. So we gotta ask ... Rosie's a good parent? Something Went Wrong Yes No I'm on Team Something Went Wrong Rosie Michelle I'd rather have dinner with ... Something Went Wrong Manny Floyd I'd rather party with ... Something Went Wrong Manny Floyd Baltimore riots mom hitting son ... Something Went Wrong Heroic Child abuse Whose side are you on? Something Went Wrong Sofia Vergara Nick Loeb Hilary Duff on Tinder ... Something Went Wrong I'd date her Swipe left Mariah in Vegas will be ... Something Went Wrong Awesome A trainwreck Courtney Stodden sex tape ... Something Went Wrong I'll watch Yuck Share on Facebook Share on X CELEBRITY JUSTICE ™