Is Broadway the "American Idol" Graveyard?

The Great White Way is riddled with the discarded musical corpses of former "American Idol" wannabeens of yore.
Anthony Federov, Fantasia Barrino, Diana Degarmo, Frenchie Davis, Constatine Maroulis, Tamyra Gray
As of May 29, Season One finalist Tamyra Gray will join the cast of "Rent" (she previously starred in "Bombay Dreams"), and simultaneously, rejoins the club of former "A.I." contestants who have been making ends meet on Broadway. It's not a J.Hud Oscar but it beats the late shift at Applebees!

Other contest losers trading Hollywood dollar bills for Playbills include: Season Two's impeached diva Frenchie Davis, who has been performing in "Rent" off and on for four years, Season Four's creepy crooner Constantine Maroulis, who hammed it up in "The Wedding Singer" last year, and Anthony Federov (memba him?), who just this month joined the revival of long-time hit, "The Fantasticks." While Diana Degarmo, who came in second on Season Three, took a break from her soccer-mom 'do and non-existent record sales to don a beehive in "Hairspray."

Even Fanatasia Barrino, who actually won "Idol" and at one time sold millions of records, has hit the NYC stage. To her defense, Miss B. has been getting rave reviews and selling out the house as Miss Celie in Oprah's production of "The Color Purple."

So while America may have become immune to the McPheever ("Over It," anyone?), you never know, she may just turn up on Broadway -- in "Kats."



Tags: Anthony Federov, AnthonyFederov, Constantine Maroulis, ConstantineMaroulis, Diana Degarmo, DianaDegarmo, Fantasia Barrino, FantasiaBarrino, Frenchie Davis, FrenchieDavis, Tamyra Gray, TamyraGray

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 4) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. Contrary to popular West Coast opinion, Broadway is a great showcase for talented voices.
I realize there's little in the way of culture on the left-coast, but dayum!

Posted at 12:25PM on May 8th 2007 by Still Great

2. Well, I don't know about Broadway.
But I really love Simon, and last night I had a dream about Simon and he asked me to be his girlfriend. I said, of course, YES. Later I caught him in bed with Terri Seymour. Then I woke up.

Posted at 3:50PM on May 8th 2007 by Jenn

3. And Josh Strickland plays Tarzan!

Posted at 2:15PM on May 8th 2007 by Kimberlie

4. Interesting non-story. The American Idol name has given these people a foot in the door that they might never had had and no matter how long lived the role..its better than unemployment. Tamyra took over the role on Bombay Dreams too late to save it but she will shine in Rent and remind everyone what a superstar they let get away in Season One. She's not a one trick pony and will be successful for a long time.

Posted at 12:29PM on May 8th 2007 by MissCongeniality

5. How does starring on Broadway make one a "loser"? News flash: Not everyone wants to live in LA (AKA Mexican Heaven)

Posted at 12:37PM on May 8th 2007 by Reality check

6. One more thing: American Idol IS....the American Idol Graveyard. No one with an I.Q. over 56 gives a rip about it

Posted at 12:45PM on May 8th 2007 by Reality check

7. could kelly clarkson be anymore washed up? tell me you all saw this article http://collegecandy.com/2007/05/08/kelly-clarkson-youre-new-song-sucks/

Posted at 12:40PM on May 8th 2007 by FY22

8. Nice way to spin it, TMZ. I actually saw Diana DeGarmo in Hairspray and she was fabulous. I believe she did Broadway for close to a year, far longer than any of the other Idol alumni. I was skeptical of an American Idol contestant in one of my favorite Broadway roles, but she impressed me and other Broadway fans alike. Also, she doesn't look like that picture there at all.

Broadway is a hard business. Either you cut it or you don't. 8 shows a week is no joke. For anyone who can play that schedule, major kudos to them. Not every American Idol contestant can do it.

Frenchie got mixed reviews for her role, as did Tamyra and Constantine. Diana and Fantasia both received rave reviews.

Posted at 11:23PM on May 17th 2007 by Louanne

9. #6 speak for yourself.

Oh, and BTW, I was at the taping of A.I. last Wednesday, with good seats and saw my love, Simon. He is hot. To me he is. Antonella sat in my row. Not much to look at...at all. I was quite surprised. Very plain face. Little girl with big droopey a s s.

Simon is 'THE MAN'. LOL. But he is.

Posted at 12:58PM on May 8th 2007 by Jenn

10. I would rather have a TONY than a GRAMMY thank you very much. It's harder to make it on Broadway than in the music. People are constantly putting down Broadway as if it's a bad thing. To make it there means you have actual talent rather than having your voice computerized 3 ways from Sunday in order to make a hit.

Posted at 1:04PM on May 8th 2007 by Dannie

11. Hey Jenn, thanks for proving my point. You're a numbskull. Simon has abysmal taste in....well, everything. Just like you!

Posted at 1:06PM on May 8th 2007 by Reality check

12. There is nothing to be ashamed of for being in a broadway play. Lots of people try out and don't make it on Broadway. What people should be ashamed of is the way they are grouping the whole West Coast as one because of one writers opinion. We do have culture here and by the way Realty Check L.A. is just one area of the state. It seems to me you are just a racist and feel the need to address that when it has nothing to do with the article.

Posted at 1:09PM on May 8th 2007 by Andrea

13. Realty Check, you need a realty check. I could care less about American Idol. Your comments have nothing to do with what I said and your racist remarks have nothing to do with the article.

Posted at 1:20PM on May 8th 2007 by Andrea

14. Let's see what a choice.

Either be trapped in a recording contract that rips you off or perform on Broadway?

I'll take Broadway !

Posted at 1:34PM on May 8th 2007 by ronnyk

15. Now you're putting down BROADWAY!! The great white way? Oh, Please, TMZ...Shows such as Mame, Gypsy, Cats, Chorus Line, Phantom and so many more have given us so much wonderful music, so many amazing stars?! How ridiculous you are.

Posted at 1:30PM on May 8th 2007 by Joan

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments