Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

"Lost" Diary -- Another Woman

3/7/2008 6:57 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF

"So because last week's 'Lost' was so good, does that automatically mean that this week's has to suck?"

That was the IM I got from my friend Chris on Thursday morning and now I have the fear of God in me. Is it possible? Can "Lost" be that good last week and this week too? One can only hope ...

For all you "Lost" Diary newbies, here's how it goes: I gather with a group of friends watching "Lost," writing what happens on the show as it happens, and throwing in my two cents along the way. I am watching tonight's episode of "Lost" alone as Ari and Lauren are in Las Vegas. How is it I get emails from total strangers wanting to watch "Lost" with me and my own friends bail on my constantly? Let's roll:

9:00 -- Time for my new favorite game: flashback or flashforward? Now, I know all we have had so far this season are flashforwards, but I don't think we're done with flashbacks just yet -- at least I hope. I'm going flashback, but I know I'm probably wrong.

9:01 -- Hang on a sec, isn't Tom dead? Has to be a flashback.

9:02 -- "Welcome to the island." -- Harper to Juliet. Winner!!!

9:03 -- "We want you to feel at home." Ben to Juliet. As always, even the most gracious words sound ultra-creepy when Ben says them.

9:04 -- Faraday and Charlotte have gone missing, and on cue it begins raining, the island starts whispering and Harper appears out of nowhere. I'm assuming she's real, but you never know with "Lost."

9:07 -- Ok, so Faraday and Charlotte are headed to the tempest (whatever that is) to release the gas and kill everyone -- or at least that's what Ben thinks.

9:08 -- "Ben is exactly where he wants to be." -- Harper. Didn't Miles say the same thing when Kate had him tied up in that shed?

9:09 -- Under the cover of whispers (yes, I said whispers), Harper disappears. Seriously, WTF?!!?!??

9:10 -- All our favorite dead Others are back this week. Good times.

9:11 -- Apparently Harper is Goodwin's wife. Now, we know Harper is still alive and we know Goodwin and Juliet got it on -- so I guess that means Juliet is a slut.

9:12 -- Once again, Jack asks someone a really, REALLY important question -- but when they don't answer, he just let's it go. Jack might be a great doctor, but he'd make a shitty cop.

9:13 -- Based on their conversation, it sure seems like Faraday and Charlotte are planning on doing what Ben thinks they are planning on doing. Ben's never really wrong.

9:17 -- Kate, for a change, is not acting like an idiot and asking all the right questions.

9:18 -- Wait, scratch that.

9:19 -- "It's very stressful being an Other, Jack." -- Juliet

9:20 -- Goodwin busts in on Ben and Juliet with the offer of an egg salad sandwich -- that sly dog!

9:21 -- Harper knows Juliet has been sleeping with her husband and apparently Harper is afraid of what Ben would do. And did you catch Harper's "You look just like her comment"? Has to be Annie, right?

9:22 -- Claire wants to interrogate Miles to find out why he and his crew are really on the island -- and she's actually making sense, which confuses me. Charlie dying has done wonders for her.

9:23 -- "Don't you want to know whose boat it is?" -- Claire

9:24 -- Ben and Locke are throwing out so many good quotes, I can't even keep up.

9:26 -- Another fantastic Ben/Locke scene. First off, why doesn't Locke see that Ben is right? They are on the same side in this. And secondly, the man the freighter people work for has to be Penny's dad, right?

9:30 -- Juliet in a bikini. Not bad. Not bad at all.

9:31 -- "What's Ben gonna do?" -- Goodwin. Hmmm, something tells me we are about to find out.

9:32 -- Apparently what he can do is send Goodwin off to die.

9:33 -- Jack and Juliet find Kate passed out in the bushes -- and Juliet uses that as an opportunity to leave Jack behind.

9:34 -- I need silence please -- Locke and Ben scene, Locke and Ben scene, Locke and Ben scene!!!

9:35 -- "I taped over the game." -- Ben. Has the playing of any tape on "Lost" ever not been completely awesome? I am downright giddy right now.

9:36 -- Ladies and gentlemen, Charles Widmore.

9:37 -- "If 5,000 people came out to see a piece of mold, how many people do you think would come here to see you?" -- Ben to Locke

9:38 -- Ben just told Locke that the Widmore file is "the last bargaining chip" he has left. Now that I don't believe.

9:39 -- Last chance -- who is Ben's man on the boat?

9:43 -- Hold the phone -- Jack just got a straight answer out of Kate!!! First time for everything.

9:44 -- Out of all the creepy things Ben has said and done, where does cooking a ham rank? It's got to be up there.

9:45 -- Zach and Emma are on the list, apparently. I love all the "list" talk, but when do we actually get to find out something about it?


9:52 -- Faraday is trying to say that he's trying to make the gas inert. He'd be more convincing if he weren't wearing a GAS MASK!!!

9:52 -- Cat fight.

9:54 -- Ok, so Faraday succeeded in making the gas inert so that Ben couldn't use it against them later. I'm having some problem figuring out what to make of all this.

9:56 -- Ben couldn't just tell Juliet that Goodwin was dead, he had to show her his rotting, decaying corpse.

9:57 -- "How could you possibly not understand that you're mine?" -- Ben to Juliet. That's not creepy, it's just kinda sad (with a touch of crazy thrown in).

9:59 -- Jack and Juliet finally kiss. I don't have Lauren hear to gauge the female reaction, but let me try. "That slut!"

10:00 -- "See you guys at dinner." -- Ben

"So because last week's 'Lost' was so good, does that automatically mean that this week's has to suck?"

Eh, guess so.

Look I can't flat out declare this episode a clunker, but it really did only one thing for me and that's question my undying love for Ben. I know he wants to protect the island at all costs, but I am starting to doubt how pure his intentions really are. Is he really all about the island -- or is he all about himself?

The rest of this episode (I think we all suspected the freighter was Widmore's) I could have done without. I give it a C+. The Ben/Locke scenes were great and Juliet in a bikini did not disappoint. Hey, I'm still a guy here!

Here's my question to you this week: Even though "Lost" has cut its season down to 16 eps (and even less after the strike) we're still getting dud episodes. Is "Lost" better served with even fewer eps, say 12? Works for HBO, Showtime and FX. Just a thought.

Over at, I do a question-and-answer column every week. I had to skip this week because my laptop is in the shop and I can't get to all the email. Don't feel like you have to ask a straightforward "Lost" question. Have fun with it. Click here to send me a question.

No Avatar

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments


Thanks for the interesting news

2290 days ago


I agree! What a mediocre episode. Been watching this from the pilot and LOVE this show. Best on TV I say. But Juliet, come on, she didn't even have a beginning on the island. She is a newbie to me. I don't care for her with jack either, makes him look weak, I love her, no I don't, I love her, no I don't, etc. Duh! Want more scenes with Sawyer! Love the lines, the look, the everything. C+ is a fair rating I say, KUDOS!

2316 days ago

Lindsey HerpeHan    

Michael has to be the guy on the boat working for Ben!

2316 days ago


Bens man on the boat is sayid. Because since there is a time shift between the boat and island and more then one person can split time now I bet thats who it is, and with the whole flash forward it all ties together.

2316 days ago


I wouldn't call it a clunker, just not one of the best. I don't trust Ben at all. I'm glad he taped over a Red Sox tape, since I'm from St. Louis!!!!!

2316 days ago


Yes she was boring until last night, she doesnt bother me as much now but...I wanted to vomit when she kissed Jack to those two

2316 days ago

31 minute difference....    

loved all the great Ben lines in this episode, especially the closing "See you guys at dinner"

2316 days ago


I love your recaps of the show!

2316 days ago


I'm with you Daniel...kinda boring of an episode. I wanted to know WHO was his man on the boat?
And who is Annie? Ben's mom? Faraday/Charlotte and Jake/Juliet have the same look going on with the dark hair, scruffy beards and the women with their curly, long hair...hhmmmm...AND what does Clare want with Miles?

2316 days ago

Frank Fourfingers    

Jack is P whipped. Every woman on the island manipulates him. The episode was decent but I need more answers. And it has to be Michael on the ship right?

2316 days ago


I think that Michael is the man on the boat.

2316 days ago


I love how they are slowly starting to tie up the loose ends like what ended up happening to Goodwin when he went off to find the survivors in season 1

2316 days ago


I agree Daniel, this episode wasn't the best. But one thing I always keep in mind with LOST, is that there is SO much going on that sometimes you have to have these "informational" episodes to set up something big later on. Also, in this episode we learned about the "history" between Ben and Juliet, and now the friction between them makes more sense. I always tell myself that not EVERY episode can be the best episode ever - with LOST you have to have patience, which I know you know. ;)

I would definitely NOT be ok with less episodes! Even if they're not the "slam dunk" episodes like last week's "The Constant", they are still LOST - and I LOVE LOST! ;)

2316 days ago


OK, so the man Ben has on the boat, could it be Locke? In a time travel, sort-of-future version of himself? Why else would Ben tell him "you better sit down" before telling him? It wouldn't be a complete surprise to Locke if Ben said it was Walt or Michael....I don't think anyone thinks they actually left. What else would be so shocking to Locke?

2316 days ago


when will Claire and Jack figure out they share a father? Why does Kate have Jack's nephew in the flash forward? I love Locke !! He is the man !

2316 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web