Carly Smithson -- Amateur Butt Cleaner

Her hair looks like a yellow helmet.

Kimberly Caldwell is amazing!

Yes- she is amazing. An amazing no-talent bimbo who still hasn't recorded an album seven years post Idol.

Is there an age limit for watching TMZ or coming to their site. That's kind of crazy if there is. It's on late night when all the big girls are still up so they should be able to watch it. Kimberly Caldwell is NOT gorgeous. She looks like an old worn out helmet head. That hair is just bad. Her singing is bad and her reputation is bad. The best thing Carly could do is run as far as she can as fast as possible. Nothing good can come of that relationship.

The best thing David Cook ever did was dump her dirty ass.

I agree with poster #22 .... David Cook is soooooooooo much better off without that no-talent slut ... she disgusts me and so does Carly. They are both talentless attention whores .... The reason why they haven't been successful, you ask??? The public can see right through their phony asses. TMZ, stop giving these whorebags any attention and hopefully they'll go away.

ick, the latest rumor is that these two sluts are disgusting everyone all over L.A.
TMZ, don't give them any attention and maybe they'll go away! They are not talented; they don't have careers, and will never have careers of any substance in L.A. Skankwell gave it a try since 2002 ... sorry, it didn't work. Idol tonite is her only real gig, and that's wearing off. Carly is not likable ... she'll never make it in the music industry.
Time to pack it in, losers! Hollywood skank is the only level you'll ever achieve.