Martins Ferry Police Chief Barry Carpenter and Bridgeport Police Chief Chad Dojack were all booked into the Belmont County jail at around 9 PM. It's unclear at the moment what charges they face.
A third man was also arrested in connection with the case -- that guy happens to be the son of Bridgeport's mayor.
Investigators claim the men hatched a plot to swipe valuable information from the surrogate's home in Martins Ferry -- including voice mails left by SJP -- which were to be sold to a tabloid.
All three men posted bond shortly after the arrests.
The surrogate gave birth on June 23 to twin girls.