Metcalfe vs. Jenner: Who'd You Rather?!

BOTH hey, hey!!! YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYYYY!!!!

Overall, Brody is hot! That picture does not do him justice, and his whole personality is fun! Jesse is too much of a pretty boy, with overplucked eyebrows, yuk.

You'd have to ballgag Jenner and STD check him before I'd even get within 100 yards of him.

Oh...and a lobotomy for that bad attitude.

I would like to have them both!!!!! They are really hot!!!!!!!!!!! Hahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahaahahahahaha.

Joe Francis stated Brody has the smallest =D he has ever seen. Being Joe is a pole smoker who has seen many, that is really saying something.

this is for harvey he rather both

Who cares if they are talented? Can I have both?

Brody has a girlie-mannish vibe. A bit overly metrosexual there. Plus he's as annoying as all get out. Not manly enough! His father was kind cute in his day, though.

Clearly, both at the same time!!! Harvey you need to add two options: neither and 3some!

you really should have neither or death as a option.

Provided they are both STD free, and I can remove Brody's ability to talk other than to ask if I like it, I'm in the both catagory.

WTF?! someone said they look mexican??

Neither. I would take Brody's brother, Brandon.

I've had a crush on Jesse Metcalfe since he was on Passions' as Miguel. Lol yeah I'm a dork who cares.

I can't believe Jesse's winning. Brody's way hotter. Jesse's lost his Desperate Housewives body