'American Idol' Judges: Who'd You Rather?

Did not watch show . but saw snippets of it and other than Randy Jackson .. what a mess . end of 'this series' Tyler looked like he was into porn and Jennifer NO talent for this as well .. Judges, you say .. LOL

Tyler was not bad..ok aside from the creepy leering at a 16 yo but did not see over-the-top antics. JLo, otoh, should stop making everything about her; I did this...I saw that...I used to sing this...etc etc.

I don't think that you can compare. They are all different. I have been a fan since day 1 and will remain a fan no matter what!

u got to be kidding....jo vs paula...who would pick paula...j-ho all the way!

better judge, it has been on ONE TIME and we should be comparing

I 'D RATHER JUDGE JUDY

Really, I would not say that you are mature at all!

I'm just glad that DiGuardio or whatever her name is, is long gone.

@dd
Amen to that!

It was funny how most of the contestants would walk in and just stare at j-lo or tyler,better than I thought it would be but still not as good as the first or second season when it was really real...
It is sort of weird to see these young girls come on and you can tell all grandpa tyler would have to do is snap his fingers and they would definitly get naked,

Her music may suck, but JLo is HOT!

The show SUCKs. I am a professional musican and you ass kids need to pay your dues and get there the hard way and not on some ****y show. What a waste of tv and the has been judges who are in love with themselfs.

Paula is a big fat loser. Suck it up, loser!

#13

THO I AGREE FOR THE MOST PART WHAT U SAID, U SOUND LIKE A BITTER FAT ASS 50+YR OLD WHO HASNT MADE IT YET. GIVEN THE CHANCE, IMMA SURE YOUR OLD ASS WOULD BE RIGHT UP THERE WITH J. HO AND STEVEN TYLER. TRUTH...

hi im only 14 yrs old and let me tell u, u guys sound immature. i deal with alot of stuff in highskool and yall just sound like abunch of 12 yr olds.....:)