TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Nicole vs. Cheryl

Who'd You Rather?

5/26/2011 4:30 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Former Pussycat Dolls lead singer Nicole Scherzinger, 32, just replaced former Girls Aloud member Cheryl Cole, 27, on the U.S. version of "The X Factor."

0526_nicole_cheryl

Question is ...

132 COMMENTS

No Avatar
91.

karen    

Firstly..to people who say Cheryl has proved her worth because of how she has done on OUR x factor the simple fact is that for the three years she was a judge on it she was given the two easiest categories every single time. She never once had the groups or the over 25s.

Secondly Nicole was a judge on our show last year and its pretty fair to say that after Cheryls antics last year that most would have preferred Nicole to be a judge on our show full time. Incidentally the fact that Cheryl had a act in the top two last series wasnt really down to Cheryl either..it was down to another mentor helping her because all Cheryl cared about was her little mini me Cher and once she thought she was going to get on the US version her behaviour totally sucked.

And to people who say shes sweet..sure she is..thats why shes got a conviction for decking a toilet attendant earning her the nickname " biffa".

Incidentally to the person who says she has lovely hair...if you have the money you can buy extentions to have hair like hers.

1142 days ago
92.

karen    

@Dochelle..what famous people fell out with Cheryl because she stayed with Ashley?

And for the record its strongly rumoured that in actual fact her and Ashley are still seeing each other.

1142 days ago
93.

Lydiamonds    

Erm- for all those still thinking they have a leg to stand on saying that Cheryl ir racist against black people- er did you miss the fact she was MARRIED TO A BLACK MAN?!

I didnt like Cheryl at first, but I have to admire her spirit for not only putting up with the love of her life cheating, and her battle with Malaria she picked up in Africa...all of which she had to do being the no.1 biggest star in the UK. No her singing isnt the best Ive heard, but I like her songs, she's an incredible dancer, and when she walks into a room eyes are on her- as all the best entertainers do.

Beyond anything else- I think America would have enjoyed the different aspect Cheryl would have brought- the US is saturated with lairy outspoken women with a chip on their shoulder for no reason (aka Nicole)...Cheryl's sweet yet feisty approach is something new and why she is the UK sweetheart!

1142 days ago
94.

karen    

Lydiamonds

Thanks for the laugh lol. She isnt and never has been the biggest star in the Uk. When you think of all the stars here..im puzzled how anyone can think shes the no 1 biggest star here. At the end of the day shes a lucky girl. She doesnt have a great deal of talent and struck gold by getting a job on the X Factor..and then people felt sorry for her cause of Ashley,

After the outrage over Gamu..the way she behaved on x factor..went at Wagner..i really dont think shes the Uk sweetheart lol. In fact there was a far far bigger outrage when it was said that Danni wasnt coming back to the show than there was about Cheryl.

1142 days ago
95.

Lydiamonds    

She is the biggest star in the UK Karen- and I say that actually not being her biggest fan (and in fact my best mate despises her also). However, you cannot deny the fact that she dominates the UK press, just turn onto BBC News 24, look at the newspapers for tomorrow. Glossy magazines are dominated by her on the cover, she's won FHM top 100 previously, she's had twenty top 20 singles in Girls Aloud, 2 no.1 selling albums, no.1s as a solo artist, a hugely successful Loreal Campaign...the list is endless. Whether or not you think she deserves it is different. As I said, I dont think she's the best singer, but then that doesnt make you a star. There are thousands of amazing singers rattling around this country who will never be big, because it's more than just your voice. She is a very good dancer by the way, and she works on screen, and she gets people talking.

I came on here not as her biggest fan (although I do admire her perserverence- and her handling of the press, I would hate her life in that regard)...but I was annoyed by this reasoning it may be because of her accent- and well they want to replace her with Nicole Scherzinger who really IS awful- she really is a diva who thinks she's better than everyone else.

1142 days ago
96.

Joan Sinnott    

Glad Cheryl is gone. Shes more style than substance and that gets boring after a while.

1142 days ago
97.

UNLEVINED HARVEY    

faaaaake booooobs

1142 days ago
98.

karen    

Lydiamonde im sorry but i totally disagree with you. She is not the biggest star in this country .. im not sure whether you mean the biggest star in the uk to include everything..but there are far far bigger stars than her here. In fact several papers/articles ive read today and people have asked who IS Cheryl Cole? I Would say til the beginning of the last series i was a fan of hers but her behaviour was disgusting and now i am not. Yes shes had number one singles BUT..everyone whose appeared on the x factor sold a lot after there appearance and lets be honest here after her appearance singing..oops i mean miming there was outrage over here.../that someone judging others didnt even sing live herself. As for the dancing yes..i saw her dancing at Chers gig where everyone said she danced like a old lady lol.

As for her accent..we can understand Geordie accents but if the Americans cant they cant...they couldnt understand Ant & Dec either. But apart from that apparently there wasnt chemistry with Paula. Personally after seeing the state our version turned into because of Cheryl and Simon im pleased for the Americans that shes not gonna be on there show.

1142 days ago
99.

Mary Bailey    

Nicole is a total flop and failure, why would anyone want her?

1142 days ago
100.

karen    

Incidentally Lydia Cheryl should never been a judge on the American version..as a Judge Nicole is far far better than Cheryl as was agreed by so many people here last year/

1142 days ago
101.

PMJ    

Maybe the Americans should learn to listen more! Like the Brits have to when we listen to all your different accents!

1142 days ago
102.

PMJ    

Maybe the Americans should learn to listen more! Like the Brits have to when we listen to all your different accents!

1142 days ago
103.

PMJ    

Maybe the Americans should learn to listen more! Like the Brits have to when we listen to all your different accents!

1142 days ago
104.

karen    

PMJ in fairness though how many Americans are judging on one of our biggest shows? Except Hasselhoff and hes kinda bombing lol

1142 days ago
105.

CoolNerd    

Nicole Scherzinger is very, very brown, isn't she...?

1142 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web