TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Amanda Knox vs. Casey Anthony

Who'd You Rather?

10/3/2011 1:00 PM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

1003_whodrather
Amanda Knox was just found not guilty of the murder of her college roommate, while Casey Anthony was acquitted for the murder of her daughter earlier this year.

Question is ...


More Who'd You Rather?

223 COMMENTS

No Avatar
166.

Heather G    

You know what? This is just plain sick and of extremely poor taste. I can NOT believe that even TMZ would stoop so low as to put up 2 murderers (especially one "mother" who killed her own child) and ask such a sick question. I will never watch TMZ again nor will I go to this website again. You have sunk to an all time LOW, TRASH, DISGUSTING level.

930 days ago
167.

_Taterman    

Amanda is totally doable! Plus, she isn't a child killer. Is it me or does Casey's expression look like as if she was just caught eating a booger?

930 days ago
168.

RPK    

Its a push. They are both black widow types so you would be killed and eaten after doing either of them.

930 days ago
169.

the real diva    

amanda is innocent... whereas casey killed.. amanda is just a kid who somehow got mixed up... casey chose to kill. big difference...casey belongs in jail.... not freedom..for the rest of her life.

930 days ago
170.

Jackisagirl    

This poll is tasteless and insensitive. Amanda has been defending her sexuality and normalcy for 4 years and you thought somehow this would be appropriate. You are representative of the surfaced, money-minded, media that helped convict her in the first place. You know that feeling you get when you are going to print and wonder... "is this to far"... that's your conscience... listen to it.

930 days ago
171.

JOHO    

Casey Anthony is bat sh*t crazy and guilty. Amanda Knox is smart, educated and innocent. No contest.

930 days ago
172.

Marie    

Amanda Knox is not a murderer so she should not be mentioned in the same sentence with Casey Anthony.

930 days ago
173.

Gary    

Who wants a child killer?????????????????????

930 days ago
174.

tina    

you all are extremley sick minded for even attempting to think this is news worthy. ur site shld be taken down. disgusting pigs.

930 days ago
175.

Jack MeHoff    

I'd do Amanda Knox twice.

930 days ago
176.

Evelyn    

Really TMZ? This is offensive and disgusting. Two lives have been wrongfully taken away, and your making light of it by putting their murders in the "Who'd you Rather" section. This is wrong in a whole new level.

930 days ago
177.

Megan    

This is pretty disgusting.

930 days ago
178.

frnacisco 2010    

an option lost
Who would you rather?
Amanda
Casey
none of these american bitches

930 days ago
179.

edswoggle    

Amanda's hotter and her alleged murder involves a sex act.....+ 6 internets for her freak appeal

930 days ago
180.

Peter R.    

I thought it was who would you rather see dead.

929 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web