TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Amanda Knox vs. Casey Anthony

Who'd You Rather?

10/3/2011 1:00 PM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

1003_whodrather
Amanda Knox was just found not guilty of the murder of her college roommate, while Casey Anthony was acquitted for the murder of her daughter earlier this year.

Question is ...


More Who'd You Rather?

223 COMMENTS

No Avatar
46.

Christine    

When I saw this headline, I literally died of laughter. Like, really, TMZ? Hahahahaha. I've seen you guys do this with celebrities, but Amanda and Casey? These chicks are craycray. Just keepin' it really.

1024 days ago
47.

kelly    

That dumb a$$ mike must have put this up. He is the only one with no brains.

1024 days ago
48.

Kevin    

Classy as always TMZ!

1024 days ago
49.

me    

I don't vote in that poll -- and I hope nobody else does so even it's only for curiosity. The lowest way TMZ could chose to find out about readers' opinions.

1024 days ago
50.

Rogue Warrior    

What up all you emotionally illiterate, Nancy Disgrace following, irrational, rode wet, mental midgets???

NOT GUILTY, NOT GUILTY

1024 days ago
51.

Oh well    

All you women are just jealous because they are both hot.

1024 days ago
52.

ObamaIsAlQaeda    

What's really funny was I got home from playing golf, was taking a dump while the verdict was announced, and asked myself the same question. I'd think I'd let Amanda ride the chin while Casey took the stick. No condom necessary, I could just let her wrap it up really well with some duct tape. I hear she's good with the stuff.

1024 days ago
53.

3Storms    

Amanda, because she's actually innocent and isn't a crazed unapologetic child-murderer

1024 days ago
54.

CelebJustice    

Just when you think TMZ cant sink any lower... tasteless bottom feeders.

1024 days ago
55.

Joby    

The question is, who would I rather DESTROY...

1024 days ago
56.

Annicka    

Dude. What the ****, TMZ?? This is beyond wrong, you sick *****!

1024 days ago
57.

Shoom    

Don't 100% trust Amanda won't kill me in some rough sex, Casey has nice boobs and if you knock her up you know she'll take care of it.

1024 days ago
58.

fatherfigure5    

Well, Amanda looks better, but with Casey; you know what they say, the crazier the ****** the better the sex!

1024 days ago
59.

vincent_a    

Who would I rather WHAT? Geez!

1024 days ago
60.

Charlie Sheen    

After 4 years in prison I bet it's like new again..

1024 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web