TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Steven Tyler

JLo 'Doesn't Know'

If She's Coming Back

5/27/2012 9:01 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

0527_steven_tyler_video
Jennifer Lopez isn't just saying publicly she isn't sure if she wants to return to "American Idol," she's saying it privately too ... because Steven Tyler asked her the same question and got the same answer.

We bumped into Tyler yesterday in Malibu, and in between posing for pics with a fan, he told our photog he got a big "I don't know" when he asked JLo about her plans for next season. 

And if JLo should go, Tyler didn't offer up any specific suggestions for who should take her spot ... but he did have one general qualification he feels anyone who sits in the judge's chair should meet.

40 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

Jordan    

Steven we all know she wants more money if she gets it she will be back if not oh well. Lets hope she does not get it she is not really a judge they pay her for her name and to just sit there and be on the show she brings no real value to judging.

877 days ago
2.

stu    

he's sooooo icky.

877 days ago
3.

static    

Steven you and Gigli are both awful.

877 days ago
4.

Joey    

She should leave. She was the biggest pimp for teh Whitney Wannabe girl that deserved to lose.

877 days ago
5.

Truth    

WHO CARESSSS... THIS SHOW SHOULD BE CANNED ALREADY. BESIDES, J. HO HAS NEVER WON A F*CKING GRAMMY!! ...THO SHE'S WON 5 RAZZIE AWARDS. PEEPS SKIP OVER THAT FACT. THAT SHOULD BE THE NUMBER REQUIREMENT BEFORE ANYTHING ELSE. #TRUTH!!

877 days ago
6.

Caleigh    

Oh that Jlo keeping us all in suspense.....NOT!!!! AGT is going to bury AI anyways!

877 days ago
7.

Supr Dav     

Can't stand J-Lo.

877 days ago
8.

janet    

Who cares. This show has run it's course. What is there like 3-4 rip offs of this show. All the same thing just a different title.

877 days ago
9.

yup    

Idol should start with a clean slate.

877 days ago
10.

trish    

So, I had to watch a 30 second commercial just to see a 32 second video clip? That's not a good return on my time investment. It won't happen again.

877 days ago
11.

LasVegasResidency    

Not a big deal. her music sucks and she can't sing.

877 days ago
12.

Kari    

American idol is way bigger than any one person. It did great before she came, and it would do great if she left.

877 days ago
13.

Smarg    

Tyler and JLo both sucked at singing during the finale, really bad. They brought Jimmy in to give honest feedback in clips, but it's over. Simon Fuller, quit the show while it's still in the top.

877 days ago
14.

IceGypsy    

He's such a sweet man when he's clean and sober. Hope he stays that way.

877 days ago
15.

DaveT    

I used ta feel your fire but now it's cooooooold insi-uh-ide.....

877 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web