'Big Brother' Former Contestants Split Over Telling Frankie

7/24/2014 11:07 AM PDT

'Big Brother' & Frankie Grande's Grandpa's Death -- Should Producers Have Told Him?


"Big Brother" showdown:  2 former, famous contestants squaring off over whether producers should have told Frankie Grande about his grandfather's death.

RACHEL REILLY, Winner, Season 13.  Producers had an obligation to tell Frankie.  Death trumps show rules.  

, Contestant, Season 15.  Horrible move by producers.  It opens Pandora's Box. What happens next ... say a contestant's son has to be put under anesthesia.  Tell or don't tell?

Watch the video.  They actually both make compelling points.

So, we gotta ask ...