Home : Celebrity Justice, Miley Cyrus : Judge: Miley Cyrus Isn't So Hanoi'ing After All

Celebrity Justice
Judge: Miley Cyrus Isn't So Hanoi'ing After All

Posted Nov 20th 2009 1:27PM by TMZ Staff

Miley Cyrus won't have to find $4 billion to pay off all the Asians in Los Angeles -- a judge officially let the singer off the hook in a lawsuit over that offensive "Hanoi Montana" photo she took earlier this year.

Miley Cyrus

This morning, a judge threw out the case filed by an Asian woman named Lucie Kim -- on behalf of all the Asians in L.A. -- who claimed the photo was offensive and Miley should have known the media would get its collective hands on it.

After the photo went public, Miley apologized a bunch of times and then went on a campaign of sushi dinners.

Kim claims she's considering filing an appeal to the judge's ruling.

More Miley Cyrus



Tags: hanoi montana, HanoiMontana, lawsuit, lucie kim, LucieKim, miley cyrus, MileyCyrus

Comments [54]
SHARE |
4ie6

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 4) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. What do you expect from a hillbilly redneck?

Posted at 2:01PM on Nov 20th 2009 by xcrunk

2. Boring. Sue the dad for his creation.

Posted at 2:03PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Darrick

3. That chick is stupider than a box of rocks. Ever hear her talk? I don't think she's gone past the 6th grade.

Posted at 2:04PM on Nov 20th 2009 by xcrunk

4. It was a joke. people need to relax. blacks make fun of whites, whites make fun of blacks and everybody makes fun of asians. its all in the name of comedy.

Posted at 2:07PM on Nov 20th 2009 by slim pickin

5. Agreed, Miley is talentless. But seriously? A lawsuit? Hasn't anyone ever heard of 'Sticks & Stones'. And not to mention why this Lucie Kim isn't suing anyone else in the picture. Oh - and how about that oriental guy that's making the 'Round Eye' face? PEOPLE PEOPLE PEOPLE!!! GET REAL!!!!!

Posted at 2:08PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Lucie in the Sky with Diamonds

6. Lucie Kim needs to get a life.

Posted at 2:10PM on Nov 20th 2009 by whatever

7. these frivolous lawsuits shave to stop...

Posted at 2:11PM on Nov 20th 2009 by $$$

8. Lucie Kim needs to get a life.

Posted at 2:11PM on Nov 20th 2009 by whatever

9. #3 - I think you're the stupid one! The word, "stupider" does not exist.

Posted at 2:12PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Justin Sayin'

10. Really you can sue for anything can't u..It's a stupid picture who cares...she's a kid and they do dumb stuff..don't care if she's a celeb she 16.. we did dumb stuff like this too.. unless this photo is for the woman sue she should have been laughed right out of court..4 billion really...Dam..If people sued people for things that were offinsive we would all be standing a line to see the judge 24/7 ..She wasted time that will never be gotten back...should have done something constructive.. beside try and Milk hanna Montanna..OMg what is The world coming too..Althought this dose give me a good Ideal..How much could I get form Mj's Estate cuz he's no longer here to grace us with those GP's of his..!!!lol

Posted at 2:13PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Michelle

11. Miley Cyrus is an uneducated homely 16 yr old that needs to go away

Posted at 2:14PM on Nov 20th 2009 by geez

12. Ok, this Ms Kim is your true nipper. She's trying just to make a buck off of a famous person. Who cares anyway if someone makes fun of a certain race. I'm Italian~ a wap. I'm Mexican ~ a beaner, I'm German ~ whatever. Who cares. If everyone would just lightnen up a little bit and not be after a buck at every opportunity, the world would be a much happier place! I'm certainly NOT a fan of Miley's but stop your frivilous lawsuits. America and everyon'e stupid lawsuits are a laughing stock!

Posted at 2:20PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Addie

13. I like how the Asian dude is the only one with his eyes open!!!

Posted at 2:18PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Iro Deniro

14. Is this what our country has come to? Suing people for insulting behavior? It's a free country people... if you don't like the photo DON'T LOOK AT IT!!!!!!! Or there's always the more appealing option for people like me........ you can leave & go live somewhere else. Is there a country out there who doesn't mind tying up tax payer dollars with frivolous lawsuits over hurt feelings & scabbed boo boo's?

Posted at 2:19PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Open Minded Realist

15. Chinese (eyes made to slant one way), Japanese (eyes slant the other way), look at these ~ Boobies. Are you going to sue because I'm a woman and I have boobs? Stop this crap America. You make us expats look really stupid and continually have to answer to these frivilous lawsuits!

Posted at 2:18PM on Nov 20th 2009 by Addie

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br /> tags.