TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Ian vs. Robert vs. Tom

Who'd You Rather?

5/21/2010 2:30 PM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

"Vampire Diaries" bloodsucker Ian Somerhalder, "One Tree Hill's" Robert Buckley and "Smallville's" Tom Welling joined their CW hunk forces at an event in NYC on Thursday.

Ian  somerhalder vs. Robert buckley vs tom welling
Question is ...

57 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

NoBreederRat    

Why doesn't TMZ play Marry, Shag, or Throw off a Cliff, with us? That's a great little game of choice.



In this case, I'd shag Ian, marry Tom, and throw the other guy off a cliff. lol

1614 days ago
17.

Fb    

Tom definitely, but when he turns me down I'll be more than willing to let Ian console me.

1614 days ago
18.

fuminahara    


Part of me wants to choose Ian, but then again, I have a HUGE thing for guys who look like Clark Kent.



http://listeasy.net/

1614 days ago
19.

Irene    

Tom has great eyes.

1614 days ago
20.

imma78    

Ian forever

1614 days ago
21.

Winter    

Tom looks like Ian's older brother.

1614 days ago
22.

fair    

Ian all the way!!

1614 days ago
23.

jmac    

I have had a crush on Tom for years, and I don't even watch the show :-) He has that all-american good looks charm no doubt!

1614 days ago
24.

MrsDamonSalvatore    

Of course IAN IAN IAN IAN.. LOok at him soooo sexxy but Robert is soo sexy too but definitly Ian. But Yeah, Robert Buckley is soo damn gorgous too =) Tough choice but defintly Ian! I love my Damon Salvatore he's so irresistble.

1614 days ago
25.

shalimarfox80    

Tom Welling is the hottest man on this planet. Yummy Tom all the way!!

1614 days ago
26.

K    

Ian is just soo hot!!!, is it just me or does he look just like Rob Lowe when he was younger, those eyes!

1614 days ago
27.

K    

If i were Ian i think i would just look at myself in the mirror all day, naked at that (blushes), lol, he's the kind of guy you just want to tear his clothes off!

1614 days ago
28.

WIlson    

Tom Welling! The others don't even come close. Tom Welling is the hottest man alive!

1614 days ago
29.

o plz    

Buckley looks pasty and sweating like he's on something. The other guys look put together.

1614 days ago
30.

jimmy     

ian looks like a funny loser.



Tom Welling looks like a cool guy.

1614 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web