TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Lindsay's Jeweler: She Did This to Us Before

2/10/2011 11:30 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF

Four days before Lindsay Lohan allegedly stole the $2,500 necklace at the center of her felony case, she tried walking out of the same store with a diamond earring ... this according to the police report obtained by TMZ ... but the prior incident could actually help Lindsay's case.

0209_lindsay_lohan_police_EX_3

According to the report, on January 18, four days before the alleged necklace incident, Lindsay went to Kamofie & Company and tried on a pair of 18 karat gold white diamond earrings. Lindsay removed one earring and left the other in her ear while she shopped.

According to the report, "Ms. Lohan gathered her things and started to leave the jewelry store without making a purchase. Ms. Lohan's hair was flipped to one side covering the diamond earring."

The report states, "[The clerk] stopped her and reminded Ms. Lohan she was still wearing the earring. Ms. Lohan laughed, admitted to her mistake and removed the earring from her ear and returned it to [the clerk]."

The scenario involving the earrings is similar to Lindsay's conduct in the store when she left with the necklace.

Ironically, the earring incident could actually help Lindsay. She had absentmindedly left her own, more expensive earrings on the counter as she began walking out of the store with the single earring. And, people who know Lindsay say she's a scatterbrain who forgets basic things all the time.

Remember, trials are all about creating reasonable doubt. So she's either a klepto or forgetful... and when in doubt, the verdict must be not guilty.


0202_lidsay_lohan_accessories_fame_footer

309 COMMENTS

No Avatar
61.

john smith    

Lindsay is on ABC world news right now, remember any publicity is good publicity. Magazines and TV shows will now be offering Lindsay hundreds of thousands of dollars for interviews and photo shoots. Li Lo is laughing her way to the bank.....LOL

1317 days ago
62.

WhoKnows    

Which is it? She's scatterbrained or it was loaned to her? She must not take showers either or a week later, that necklace wouldn't still be on her neck for the photogs. She also must be deaf or else she would have heard the voicemails the jewelry store left when they called to get the necklace back.

1317 days ago
63.

lisa    

This is no different than her showing up in court wearing diamond earings, diamond bracelets, a diamond necklace, and a diamond ring. It is her way of trying to say "why would I do this when I can afford so much?"

Most kleptos can afford more than what they take it doesn't change what they do.

And who the hell wears diamonds to court?

1317 days ago
64.

Sad sad    

That makes a lot of sense. Then maybe she just lied about the loan because she was scared she was going to get into trouble. It still might have been innocent. Just speculating. Yes, if that happened she should have returned it but most people would not. Not saying that's right but that's reality.

1317 days ago
65.

AD    

@jovan Very good point but being a CelebritY in itself becomes an affliction. Many things can be mistaken as addiction including attention... add it all up its more than the average addict has to deal with... by the way every addict has a history of lying..

1317 days ago
66.

aaaaaaaaaaaaa    

stop ****ing with your lips lindsay and i'll let this slide

1317 days ago
67.

bb    

Harvey, you should really stop trying to play lawyer because unless Lohan has early-onset Alzhiemer's this is only making her look even more guilty. Leaving some of your own jewellry or a handbag on the counter is the OLDEST TRICK IN THE BOOK. That way, if they get busted on the way out they can point at the counter and say they intended on comming back and paying but they left their credit card in the car. The reason she only tried to leave with one earring was because she was TESTING this shop's security to see just how easy it is to walk out with merchandise. I wonder how many other shops Kleptohan has done over?

1317 days ago
68.

Kevin    

I wish this ugly duck billed klepto lesbo would just die already.

1317 days ago
69.

Cricket    

If they had stopped her immediately outside the store and accused her of stealing, the "scatterbrain" defense may be believable. However, she left and didn't return the necklace later so that defense is irrelevant.

1317 days ago
70.

theresa    

Actually: it demonstrates intention to perpetrate a crime: all she had to do was wait for a staff change, then go back and ask for her earrings she 'forgot'. A good 'actor' could do this very convincingly.

1317 days ago
71.

Alex Plante    


Why didn't they just send her a bill, then sue her if she didn't pay within 30 days?

1317 days ago
72.

miz    

@Alex... You're kidding us.. right?

1317 days ago
73.

Lionhearted    

Duck Lips??? I mean you are right but I just didn't think ducks had lips. I wouldn't say hideous, but appealing in a sort of pornographic way. So you are saying she is more Donald Duck than Minnie Mouse?

1317 days ago
74.

normal person    

Interesting how all you haters are expert on stealing and cons.

1317 days ago
75.

NeverSawAnyLohanFilm    

If the first Lohan incident with the jeweler is true (she left her more expensive earring at the counter), then obviously Ms. Lohan is no thief.

1317 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web