TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Pia vs. Pia:

Who'd You Rather?

4/8/2011 9:15 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Here's shockingly booted off "American Idol" babe Pia Toscano (left) -- and the OG Pia, '80s starlet Pia Zadora back in her heyday (right).

0408_pia_rather
Question is ... 

32 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

BananaHammock    

.

.

.

Pia Toscano Is Mighty Fine!!!

.

.

.

1261 days ago
2.

Jack    

Pia Toscano gets my vote.

http://bikiniheaven.info

1261 days ago
3.

Mokie    

She was the only reason to watch that show...I love the Italian girls!

1261 days ago
4.

b    

Look at that HUGE forehead. She is nasty

1261 days ago
5.

karlew    


Pia is my code name for people who piss me off. Pain In (the) Ass

1261 days ago
6.

jason    

Guys,

Check out Zadora in "When the Rain Begins to Fall" before you decide.

youtube it.

1261 days ago
7.

R    

How about a "Who'd You Rather" faceoff between Iggy Pop and Harvey? Just to give Harvey a win at something.

1261 days ago
8.

MPM    

She needed to work on her stage presence, that is something that comes with time. Her voice was right on. On the other hand, I think Randy was 100% right when he said Stefano's song started out shaky, if you youtube it, u can hear how bad the beginning sounded. Since all the judges don't really critique the performances like they should, it has become a popularity contest. Even though my guy sucked, everyone said he did great, so I will vote for him. At least Simon was real!

1261 days ago
9.

Christy    

Kesha...I thought that was Kesha on the right.

1261 days ago
10.

PacBeachKat    

She is an awesome singer but she is not an entertainer. That is why she didn't get votes. When she sings, she walks around like a zombie.

1261 days ago
11.

Superman    

I don't watch that garbage. So, you are saying she shouldn't have been booted-off because you think she's attractive?!?!? So, the singing is all a red herring? Yeah, I suspected it was all a farce!

1261 days ago
12.

David    

Pia T is one UGLY MUTT!!!!!!! Looks like the mask. I would brown bag it though. Just putting that out there.

1261 days ago
13.

Telstar    

Pia Z. is the one! And she's already put a few albums out, as well as films. The records are better, though.

1261 days ago
14.

doogie    

This is ridiculous. She sang good but had an attitude that she was the best of the best. She doesn't have 'it'. She isn't likeable. She's just so-so. I probably was the only one clapping when she was voted off. There are still 4 more that should all go with her.

1261 days ago
15.

wroser    

can't believe what people are saying about pia, my wife and i have been watching american idle since its inception so we have a good idea who is exceptional and who is not and she truely is exceptional,right up there with clarkson and lambert. america got it wrong because they didn't vote for her thinking she was a lock in, big mistake. hope you read this Pia, you are absolutely the best and we are sorry.

1261 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web