TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Steven Tyler

JLo 'Doesn't Know'

If She's Coming Back

5/27/2012 9:01 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

0527_steven_tyler_video
Jennifer Lopez isn't just saying publicly she isn't sure if she wants to return to "American Idol," she's saying it privately too ... because Steven Tyler asked her the same question and got the same answer.

We bumped into Tyler yesterday in Malibu, and in between posing for pics with a fan, he told our photog he got a big "I don't know" when he asked JLo about her plans for next season. 

And if JLo should go, Tyler didn't offer up any specific suggestions for who should take her spot ... but he did have one general qualification he feels anyone who sits in the judge's chair should meet.

40 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

Hervey....Hervey of Arabia...He was a single guy...    

Steven Tyler doesn't even know he's bee a corpse for the past decade and a half.

858 days ago
17.

uma    

Jennifer Lopez is pulling a "Shelley Long", she believes her own press, a very dangerous position to be in. First off, all the movies she is been in sucked big time including her current movie "What to Expect When You're Expecting" . Oh, and the way JLo romances the cameras on "American Idol" you would think Queen Nefertiti of Egypt is resurrected.

858 days ago
18.

3Storms    

She was a has-been before the show, and now that she's not any more, she no longer needs to use the show to get her back into fame.
.
.
She got what she wanted. She's most likely gone.

858 days ago
19.

Michelle    

nTheZone are you a little S LO W..

858 days ago
20.

brian    

Who cares? J-Lo's opinions are worth exactly 2 lumps of Chiahuahua ****. She hasn't been relevant since she married Skeletor. I love how she pretends she's bigger than Beyonce, though.

858 days ago
21.

kim    

if any one say that JLo can't sing , actually is telling that no one can sing . JLo's Performance was really great . unbelievable . perfect . and steven to but both of JLo's performance (dance again and follow the leader and going in) was incredible . i loooooove you

858 days ago
22.

KicksandGiggles    

JLo and Tyler offer NOTHING musically instructive or relevant. They are about as useful as day old pigeon poop on a stick. Randy has lost his credibility by first looking like a clown and offering minimal constructive feedback. Some of these singers were so off key, my cat ran out of the room.


BOTTOM LINE: Get rid of JLO and Tyler. Get some credible real judges (P Diddy, Diana Ross, Streisand, Madonna etc), and have a 4th seat for a viewer - fans here on this site would make a great 4th chair!

858 days ago
23.

tomas    

Steven Tyler and Bruce Jenner would make a great lesbian couple.

858 days ago
24.

SheisHot    

Sick of this show with the new breed of pandering old judges (wrinkled old JLO and Grandpa BK Tyler). Oh, and just thinking of that homo Seacrest makes me want to hurl.

858 days ago
25.

Susan62509    

When Jennifer Lopez came onboard, she basically took over. On A.I., she was a judge, in the commercials and performed on stage including bringing Marc Anthony for promotion. I thought it should have been called the Jennifer Lopez American Idol show. Jennifer used A.I. as a promotional and advertising campaign for herself and I got sick of it. Randy and Steven didn't do this. Time for a new judge to give next season some variety and a new judge to look forward to.

858 days ago
26.

who dat    

Tmz the next MySpace. Tumbleweeds are blowin through the site.

858 days ago
27.

feelicks    

let the old lady go.... why does idol always hire old farts anyway.... every judge they've ever had is/or 50yrs or older...

858 days ago
28.

ernest    

tyler behaves exactly like a 5 year old brat that long hair makes him look like a girl

858 days ago
29.

ernest    

who is that his body guard ?

858 days ago
30.

ju    

please jlo if you read this most people agree you should go take steven tyler take randy you all are to biased and have nothing to say

858 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web