« BACK TO TMZ TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Kate Upton vs. Katherine Webb

Who'd You Rather?

2/12/2013 8:20 AM PST BY Johnny Lopez

0212_whod_u_ratherIt was a battle of the super babes as Sports Illustrated cover girl Kate Upton and A.J. McCarron's overnight sensation GF Katherine Webb -- who also appears in the S.I. swimsuit issue -- brought their gorgeousness to David Letterman in NYC on Monday.

Question is ...

For more sports stories, check out tmzsports.com!
61 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

Shaunie    

Screw? I think guys would pick Upton. Bring home? Not Upton, she might screw a family member if it meant getting ahead.

597 days ago
17.

BECKER    

Kate is more attractive and playfully sexy Katherine is pretty but pretty conservative.
Kate for sure

597 days ago
18.

magica    

Threesome!

597 days ago
19.

Columbo    

Kate for sure. Her body would be a lot more fun. And you can't booby bang Katherine. :)

597 days ago
20.

Columbo    

2 to 1 are voting Kate. Seems about right.

597 days ago
21.

Jim    

Just everything else being equal, look at the shoes. Kates are Stylish Louboutin "red bottoms" and KW are cheap sandals that are too small for her. So KATE wins!

597 days ago
22.

dennis    

Abs vs. Boobs.....and the boobs take it!

597 days ago
23.

MrR    

Thank you God!

597 days ago
24.

jim bob    

KATE UPTON!!!!

597 days ago
25.

Thomas Jefferson    

Katherine is just average pretty but Kate is vavavoom!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

597 days ago
26.

unbelievable    

thats a tuff one.

597 days ago
27.

Rob    

Did you really have to photoshop Kate Upton that much? Anyone who's seen the video would know that she's not stick thin. You're doing a disservice to all young ladies by altering her image like that.

597 days ago
28.

NOT ELMO    

Katherine Webb has a Sexier Body, Prettier Eyes and is almost the same age, K-WEBB WINS!

597 days ago
29.

Crabby    

Kate Upton has a very cute pretty face as well as a sexy figure.People are attracted to her because not only is she gorgeous she looks and behaves as if she is approachable and as if she enjoys life. She is also not perfect but that makes her even more adorable. Katherine on the other hand looks as fake as a 3 dollar bill.....fake pose....fake smile....NOT sexy but she does have pretty legs.

597 days ago
30.

s_megma    

The correct answer is menage a trois. Both, of course.

597 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web