Caitlin Upton vs. Marissa Powell WHO'D YOU RATHER?

6/18/2013 12:10 AM PDT

Caitlin Upton vs. Marissa Powell: Who'd You Rather?

Here’s Miss South Carolina Teen USA 2007, Caitlin Upton at age 18 (left) … and Miss Utah USA, Marissa Powell (21) this past weekend (right) -- Both beauty queens famously bombed their responses to a pageant question.

So we gotta ask ...