Eddie Murphy's Old Chick vs. New Chick WHO'D YOU RATHER?

6/24/2013 9:30 AM PDT
Here's Eddie Murphy's 45-year-old ex-wife Nicole Murphy on a beach in Miami yesterday (left) -- and 34-year-old Australian supermodel and current Eddie Murphy girlfriend Paige Butcher on a beach in Hawaii one week earlier (right).

Both are incredibly sexy... but only one is a mother of five.

The question is...