Why would they be interested in her? Do they need a judge who can lip-sync comments to contestants?

Posted at 2:05 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Ehécatl

Have Jessica replace Ellen.

Ellen is so frigging ugly I can't stand to watch the show.

At least Jessica will give me a ha*d-*n while I'm watching.

x

Posted at 2:05 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Abe

Oh great.. someone with no talent..(other than being Sexual Napalm) judging others who have no talent... this should end well...

Posted at 2:05 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by HMD

Jessica who???????????? Has been!How about you lose fifty pound then we'll talk.

Posted at 2:07 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Roger

First Ellen with no musical background, now someone with no talent. Goodbye American Idol. Geez, how about Gilbert Godfrey as a judge? Who next.

Posted at 2:08 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by lulusez

I'm not taking this very seriously. So far I've heard Jamie Foxx, Ryan Seacrest, Harry Conick Jr., Jessica Simpson, Chris Issac, Brett Michaels, and probably others I've forgotten. This is just a game of name dropping on a show that will start plummeting in the ratings now that Cowell is gone.

Posted at 2:11 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Carl

Jessica Simpson over sings every song she does!!! How can she critic others. Maybe she should start listening to her own stuff and start criticing there first.

Posted at 2:11 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Proud Canadian

If there's a viable replacement for Simon, no one's come up with it yet.

Posted at 2:12 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Amy

I got it! The only judge that can replace Simon Cowell is Triumph the Insult Comic Dog. Now THAT I would watch!

Posted at 2:14 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by lulusez

Jess NO more BOTOX you are starting to look like joan rivers....

Posted at 2:16 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Celebrities Suck

No...no...no. She is great at many things, but this wouldn't be something that she'd excel at doing. She was live on QVC, and had a lot of trouble coming up with things to say. The other people saved her. It was something of a flop.

This would not be a fit.

Posted at 2:16 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by nobleday

Her Uncle Homer would be a better choice.

Posted at 2:17 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by JON

I'll take Bret Micheals in Simon's place. I stopped watching this show when they put in Ellen, what the hell does she know about music except to dance on her show and she's not that good at that either.

Posted at 2:17 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by Majestik

That's like poop telling vomit it stinks.

Posted at 2:18 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by yup

NO TALENT!!!!!!!!! What is she going to Judge plastic surgery???? She cant even hold a conversation even when she is'nt on drugs. Please let her just stick to Karoke night in Redneckville!

Posted at 2:22 PM on Jul 28, 2010 by boner