« BACK TO TMZ TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Kate Upton vs. Katherine Webb

Who'd You Rather?

2/12/2013 8:20 AM PST BY Johnny Lopez

0212_whod_u_ratherIt was a battle of the super babes as Sports Illustrated cover girl Kate Upton and A.J. McCarron's overnight sensation GF Katherine Webb -- who also appears in the S.I. swimsuit issue -- brought their gorgeousness to David Letterman in NYC on Monday.

Question is ...

For more sports stories, check out tmzsports.com!
61 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

steve    

way to photoshop upton's legs

564 days ago
2.

jen    

Katherine who?

564 days ago
3.

iimE    

Both are beautiful women, but I find Katherine's features a little too masculine.

564 days ago
4.

Larry    

Obviously they are both hot. But I chose Kate, because Katherine is too religious, and I wouldn't want to have to listen to the preaching, etc.

564 days ago
5.

tippy katz    

ok, I'm going to say it, and sound like a hater...
of course Katherine is beautiful but... since all this media attention began, I've been thinking she's too pretty, in that maybelline corn-fed christian way that is way too prissy to be actually attractive. Kate is bouncy inside as well as out lol.

564 days ago
6.

Pigweed    

Both.

564 days ago
7.

JBDragon    

This is 'Who would you Rather' , not really who you would want as a Girlfriend and have to talk to! That being the case, I would pick Kate by a hair, but it really wouldn't matter to me. You just can't lose either way.

564 days ago
8.

TheRealMe    

I choose boobs.

564 days ago
9.

ricosauve15    

Kate Upton all day every day

564 days ago
10.

Jude    

Kate Upton is a pretty girl but I'm sorry she has the weirdest body ever. She is thick and wide, with no curves because she is shaped like a brick. I cant believe SI put her on the cover 2 years straight looking like Sponge Bob Square Pants in an undersized bikini. There are much more toned shapely ladies out there who deserve it. I'd take Miss Alabama any day.

564 days ago
11.

jl    

Neither....I'm gay ! Sincerely, Harvey,

564 days ago
12.

Mason     

Katherine is way Hotter....Kate Upton is not my type at all.

564 days ago
13.

Violent Pope    

Kate would be more fun in the sack.

564 days ago
14.

Gargamel    

Is both at the same time an option?

564 days ago
15.

Turk182    

Honestly, both women are incredibly sexy! Either would be amazing!

564 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web