TMZ Live Heidi and Seal's Split ... Appearances Don't Mean Jack

1/23/2012 12:30 PM PST

TMZ Live -- Heidi and Seal's Split ... Appearances Don't Mean Jack

Heidi Klum and Seal's breakup shocked everyone -- they always looked rock solid in public ... but were there signs things were heading south? We lay out inside details on what was going wrong ... when cameras weren't around.

Plus, Joe Paterno's legacy -- record-setting football coach or disgraced contributor to a child sex abuse coverup? The debate is raging in America ... and our newsroom!

But we all agree Carnival Cruise lines is insulting survivors of the sinking in Italy with the worst idea since letting Captain Cowardly take the wheel!

(0:00) Heidi & Seal -- the real reason they're calling it quits.
(3:30) They seemed like the perfect couple -- renewing their vows every year ... was it all just an elaborate act?
(9:00) Seal seen wearing his wedding ring today -- someone smells a setup.
(16:01) Joe Paterno passes away from lung cancer -- what will be his legacy?
(17:50) Brian rips Penn State students for praising Paterno ... and says his legendary status helped cover up the scandal.
(30:00) Caller from Pennsylvania makes some great points.
(34:30) Beyond ridiculous -- Carnival Cruise lines is offering victims ... wait for it ... a 30% discount on their next cruise!
(39:33) Harvey just broke a massive story -- Halle Berry's baby daddy is being investigated for child endangerment.
(41:30) Havey is pissed ... that he missed the cruise ship conversation. Don't worry, he gets his two cents in ... plus change.