« BACK TO TMZ TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Accused Dodger Stadium Attacker's Photo Alibi

5/25/2011 6:00 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

The man accused of brutally beating a San Francisco Giants fan outside Dodger Stadium in March has photos which he says prove he was not even there the day of the attack.

0524_dodger_friends_ex_tmz
Giovanni Ramirez has given his lawyer pictures of a group of people who went to see the game on March 31.  The photos show Ramirez' ex-girlfriend and other friends at the park next to the stadium, but he is nowhere to be seen.  Ramirez' point -- if he was there, the pictures would prove it. 

Ramirez claims he was babysitting at his ex-girlfriend's apartment when the attack on Bryan Stow occurred.

We asked Ramirez' lawyer, Chip Matthews, why his client would hang with his ex-girlfriend.  Matthews says they remained close after the break-up.

Ramirez has not been charged and police will put him in a lineup today. 


For more sports stories, check out tmzsports.com!
171 COMMENTS

No Avatar
31.

Jake    

What kind of proof/logic is that???? What if the guy was in 25 other pictures...but he wasn't in these 3? Absence of someone in 3 photos doesn't prove anything. Come on...how often does someone appear in every picture taken at every event?

1155 days ago
32.

Shread    

I really hope they catch the guy but in fairness I don't trust The Police at all. My experience with Police has always been to stay as far away from them as possible. They lie, cheat, make up false reports and commit crimes just like criminals and i'm not alone in my thoughts. Again, i really hope this is the guy and he gets what he deserves but I still do not trust the Police at all.

1155 days ago
33.

geno     

i just looked at picture with glasses with reflection with zoom its a guy taking the picture so it might be him it looks like hes wearing a red shirt and if his probation officer turned him in he must have a record for fighting /domestic violence ,so probation officer must of thought tatoo matched his description and if this is the guy this s*** deserves to die beating a dad in front of son or daughter is not good on the kids and did someone say hewas beat with a weapon well maybe they have fingerprints on it and hes busted and do they have any witness to this brutal beating they will be there to indentify him in a lineup

1155 days ago
34.

TRW    

How is NOT being in photo's an alibi? Being IN a photo, at a location other than where you're accused of doing something bad is an alibi. Anyone can find plenty of photo's that they are not in, but it certainly doesn't prove they weren't there.

1155 days ago
35.

Big D    

Yeah right, they just randomly pick this guy out. He happens to be a Dodger fan and He stays home to watch the kids while the "ex" goes to the game. uh huh. They obviously have more evidence against the guy than to just randomly pick someone and what are the odds that the guy they pick just happens to have all his friends there. Good luck on the baby sitting story dude.

1155 days ago
36.

Stella    

these photos mean nothing!!!!

1155 days ago
37.

Scooter    

What a horrible defense! I'm not in most of the pictures on my camera either...because I'm taking the pictures!

1155 days ago
38.

Dani    

He was probably the one taking the pictures...DUH!

1155 days ago
39.

Tracy    

He may well be telling the truth, but his absence from the pictures doesn't prove a thing. Maybe he was taking them. Or maybe he just wasn't in *these* particular shots. Silly.

1155 days ago
40.

Lovely Rita    

Doesn't prove a thing. Anyway, the truth will come out soon enough. Is his ex-girlfriend the get away driver? Oh, snap!

1155 days ago
41.

Gaylord    

Deep fry the SOB!

1155 days ago
42.

OctoJihadi    

"The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence."
B Russell, bitches.

...you dont know nothing do you? Public schools.
(double negative.)

Lock his punk ass up with some real thugs so they can have some fun time with his coulo.

1155 days ago
43.

Lovely Rita    

I just noticed there is a reflection of 2 people in the sunglasses the chick is wearing. Wouldn't it be hilarious if it turned out to be the suspect snapping the photos? Oops!

1155 days ago
44.

David    

At your ex's house...really bro?? next!!!

1155 days ago
45.

Sarafina    

Looks like he was ready to go to a game...uh, TWO people wearing Dodger shirts!! Babysitting? Right.

1155 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web