TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Justin Bieber

Smoking Gun in Egging Case

Surveillance Video

2/10/2014 9:30 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

0209-bieber-egg-getty-tmz-01The L.A. County District Attorney has surveillance video that should make it pretty easy to prosecute Justin Bieber for allegedly egging his neighbor's house ... TMZ has learned.

Law enforcement sources tell us ... The L.A. County Sheriff's Department's recommendation to file felony vandalism charges focuses on 2 pieces of critical evidence:

-- Surveillance video seized during the raid at Bieber's house.  Our sources say ... the video shows Bieber in the vicinity of the area where the egging occurred at the time of the attack.  You don't actually see him throwing eggs, but he's there.  Sources connected with Bieber told TMZ earlier the video shows nothing, but that's NOT true.  The Sheriff's Dept. has given the video to the D.A.

-- A video obtained by TMZ in which you hear what sure sounds like Justin Bieber verbally going at it with the neighbor in the middle of the egging.  At one point you ever hear Bieber scream, "F*** you!  I got another one for you actually."  The video is too dark to actually see him.

In addition there are 2 eyewitnesses ... the neighbor ... who openly has beef with Bieber -- and his 13-year-old daughter.  The girl made a 911 call which our sources say matches the time Bieber was seen on the surveillance video.

The 2 videos make it almost impossible for Bieber to deny he was throwing the eggs -- it would be shocking if the D.A. doesn't file criminal charges.

The open question -- will the D.A. file the case as a FELONY or a misdemeanor?  The neighbor has submitted repair estimates totaling around $20,000.  If a vandal destroyed an expensive car the D.A. would probably view it as a felony.  The issue is whether the D.A. will appreciate that eggs can cause that much damage on an expensive home.

The D.A's decision should come down this week.

011014_bieber_eggs_launch_v3

273 COMMENTS

No Avatar
91.

RB    

There are no lights in the neighborhood, and it’s dark. The first thing Justin’s attorneys are going to ask is: can you describe what he was wearing? Also, Justin’s surveillance video shows Justin’s in the vicinity of the area; the skateboard ramp is on the side of the neighbor’s house. The egging occurred at the neighbor’s front door. Maybe someone egged the neighbor’s house and Justin just happened to be at his skateboard ramp skating. Was Justin set up?

221 days ago
92.

rcarol    

As punishment, Bieber should be ordered to wear an Easter Bunny costume, personally color Easter eggs and distribute them to all the children at Cedars Sinai.

221 days ago
93.

fleabag73    

WHERE is this little brats' Momma? He needs an ass whoopin something FIERCE, he's gonna get away with this, celeb justice and he's headed La Lohan if he keeps this sh#t up. Please deport his ass.

221 days ago
94.

DougDiPlacido    

They seriously need to deport this creep. We do not need taxpayer money wasted in the court system on a moron.

221 days ago
95.

Miamivic    

Bieber could face prison time over the pot plane.

http://www.nbcnews.com/news/investigations/bieber-could-face-prison-over-pot-plane-n26506

221 days ago
96.

CaliCakes702    

We all know nothing is going to happen to this punk. They'll just make him pay for it and issue a formal apology.

221 days ago
97.

ElectricCrochet    

In his defense (chokes back laughter) this kid spent most of his teenage years working his butt off. He is now re living it! So when is someone going to snatch him up and lock his tail in a studio until he uses his brain?

221 days ago
98.

wornoutmama    

Idk why this crap is even reported because we all KNOW that no charges will be brought against him. They'll settle and the world will keep spinning.

221 days ago
99.

Don    

If I were the offended neighbor, I'd burn this little punk's butt right to the ground. Hollywood is now known as the
breeding gound of entertainment trash !

221 days ago
100.

BLUEJAY    

GUYS THE PROBLEM IF HE DOESN'T HAVE A EGG CARTON IN HIS HAND OR A EGG THEIR NOW WAY HE CAN BE CONVICT ALL THE HAVE TO SAY THE NIEGHBR WAS OUTSIDE WAITING FOR HIM TO COME HOME BASE ON THE STORY THE NIEGHBOR HAD HE WAS OUT SIDE ON THE PATTIO HE PROBLEM SAW HIM COME HOME WHAT GOING TO HAPPEN SHE GOING TO LOOK AND IF THEIR A TRUCK OR A CAR THAT THE POLICE MISSED ON BOTH VIDEO THAT GOT GOING TO HELP HE WOULD HAVE A CAR DIP****S WITH HIS LIGHT ON THAT WOULD BE TO EASY TO SEE HIM AND HE A LOT SMARTER THEN THAT I READ IN THE LOS ANGLES TIME THE POLICE HAVE NO EVEDINCE HE WAS EVEN HOME AT THE TIME I TRUST THEM MORE THE I TRUST TMZ SOURCES. THIS SOUND LIKE A TMZ PAID STORY 20,000 DOLLAR IS THEIR PICE TO MAKE UP STORY.

221 days ago
101.

dutch belieber    

Seriously why are you so against justin? you act like a murderer or criminal?! justin know you personally? NO! I do not, but I also know justin his good side and knows that he is not a bad man! He really does not deserve this!! you are sooo childish!! do not be so stupid and simply write the good things of justin on your site!

Greetings a belieber from the Netherlands

221 days ago
102.

charlie    

Just lock him up and throw away the key.....

221 days ago
103.

Growthefu##kupJustin    

If I was his neighbour and he did this to my house I would
sue the crap out of him. Or send a few men to his house at 2 in the morning in a blacked out van wearing masks. Bundle him into the back of the fan and scare the living crap out of him then drop him naked in the worst part of LA and leave him to make his own way home. That's if he makes it home.

221 days ago
104.

Loading...    

How is it "almost impossible for Bieber to deny he was throwing eggs??" You just stated that the video does not show Bieber throwing the eggs. Just because he was standing near the area does not mean he did it. The witnesses did not actually see Bieber throwing the eggs. They are making an assumption. All you hear is Bieber and the neighbor yelling obscenities to each other. So, I don't see how this case is "pretty easy" to prosecute. I'd like to know why the neighbor (as angry as he was) did not call the police right away for disturbance of the peace? Unless that video clearly shows Bieber throwing eggs, the evidence is only cir***stantial and coincidental. A jury will want to clearly see the video with Bieber throwing the eggs. And let's see here: how many eggs were there that caused that much damage? Good luck finding the exact egg(s) that Bieber threw for absolute conviction. Is it possible that the neighbor caused his own damage just to antagonize the situation?

221 days ago
105.

BLUEJAY    

DUDE IF HE DIDN'T HAVE ANY EGG THE GUY COULD OF SAW HIM COMING HOME WENT OUT THEIR CUSSED HIM OUT AND OTHER STUFF. YOUR SOURCES AREN'T THAT GREAT DID THEY SAID HE WAS GOING TO GET CHARGE WITH ASSAULT BUT HE WASN'T CHARGE AT ALL. THIS IS THE SAME PERSON THAT OUT TO GET HIM. YOUR SOURCES WAS WRONG ABOUT THE DRUGS IN THE HOUSE AND DIDN'T EARLY SAID THE WAS NO EVEDINCE FOUND FROM THE SAME ****ING SOURCE. DO NO EGGS. THE ONLY THING IS THE GUY CUSSING OUT SOMEONE HELL YOU GUYS COULD OF PAY SOMEONE TO EGG THEIR OWN HOUSE AND BLAME IT ON BIEBER THAT SOUND LIKE KIND OF A PAYMENT YOU GUYS TRY TO GET ROBIN VERRECAS TO BEAT UP A WOMEN AND PRETEND HE WAS JUSTIN BIEBER FOR 20,000 DOLLARS NOW IS THAT STRANGES.

221 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web