'American Idol' to Benardo: Dismiss Suit or You'll Pay
"American Idol" is firing back at Ian Benardo, warning the former contestant to dismiss his lawsuit ASAP, or he'll end up paying the show's enormous legal defense costs.
As we previously reported -- Benardo sued "Idol" in federal court in New York last month, claiming "Idol" producers "exploited" his sexual orientation by asking him to "gay it up" on their show.
"Idol" lawyers shot back last week with a letter reminding Benardo that he long ago signed an agreement releasing the show from any liability.
The agreement reads, "I [Benardo] further understand that my appearance, depiction and/or portrayal in the Program may be disparaging, defamatory, embarrassing, or of an otherwise unfavorable nature which may expose me to public ridicule, humiliation or condemnation."
"Idol" lawyers also claim Benardo's contract clearly states that if he sues them and loses, he's going to have to pay all their legal fees -- and you can bet "Idol" lawyers don't come cheap.
UPDATE: Benardo tells TMZ, "I will see them in court. They want me to be quiet about this and I’m not going to back down just because they are a major tv show."
More American Idol
'Idol' Judge Steven Tyler Aerosmith Jealous of Me
Steven Tyler claims his Aerosmith bandmates were "jealous" when he became an "American Idol" judge ... interesting, considering Joe Perry recently slammed Tyler for getting involved with the show.
Tyler explained the band's ongoing beef today after his long-awaited "Idol" unveiling -- but added that when push comes to shove, "I'm sure they're real happy for me."
Sure they are.
More American Idol
TMZ Live: Lohan, Gibson, and 'American Idol'
We took your questions today on everything -- including Mel Gibson's letter to Oksana Grigorieva, Lindsay Lohan may be heading back to jail, and the bad omen for "American Idol."
Plus: Madonna fan arrested outside her NYC apartment.
Bad Omen for 'American Idol'
It was the buildup of the summer ... "American Idol" unveiling its new panel of judges -- Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez and Randy Jackson. Everyone was in place. Except for the audio guy.
Ryan Seacrest took the stage and the whole thing went down ... and no one heard a word.
Anyone superstitious?
More American Idol
TMZ Live: Lindsay, Oksana, and Adam Lambert
We took your questions on everything -- including Lindsay Lohan failing a drug test, Oksana Grigorieva making it official with her new lawyer Sorrell Trope, and Adam Lambert accused of battery in Miami.
Plus: Katherine Jackson's lawsuit against AEG not including Dr. Conrad Murray.
Adam Lambert -- Accused of Battery
TMZ has learned ... the Miami Beach Police Department is now in the middle of a violent incident involving "American Idol" runner-up Adam Lambert ... after the alleged victim filed a police report.
Law enforcement sources tell us the paparazzo seen grappling with Lambert on the beach yesterday walked into a Miami Beach police station around 10:30 PM last night and filed a report ... accusing the singer of misdemeanor battery.
According to the police report, obtained by TMZ, the victim claims Adam grabbed his backpack "where the camera was placed" ... and "wrestled [the photog] to the ground forcefully."
One big problem -- in photos that were taken of the incident, the camera appears to be in the photog's hand ... not in his bag.
The police report also notes that the photog didn't sustain any "bruises or lacerations."
Cops tell detectives will decide if the case is worth turning over to the State's Attorney -- who will decide whether to prosecute Lambert. If convicted, Lambert could face up to one year in jail and a $1,000 fine.
After yesterday's clash -- Lambert went right to his Twitter account and posted, "I lost my temper for a sec but wow it felt great lol MIAMI!!!"
UPDATE: Lambert just tweeted, "Battery? Nope. I attempted to grab a camera, no punches were thrown and no one was on the ground.... It was literally harmless. If embarrassment is a crime- thats all I'm guilty of. "
See also
TMZ Live: J.Lo, Fishburne, and Reggie Bush
We took your questions today on everything -- including Jennifer Lopez signing on with "American Idol", George Michael sentenced to 8 weeks in jail, and Montana Fishburne trying to get her life back together.
Plus: Reggie Bush forfeits his Heisman Trophy.
Jennifer Lopez Is a Go On 'Idol' ... for One Year
TMZ has confirmed ... Jennifer Lopez has signed a 1-year deal with "American Idol" for "a little more than $12 million" -- this according to sources connected with the show.
It's somewhat surprising that the deal is only for one year ... given the nature of the "A.I." franchise.
Nonetheless -- as first reported by Nikki Finke at DeadlineHollywood.com, it is a done deal and Jennifer Lopez is expected to be at the judges' table for auditions next week.
More American Idol
FOX: Someone's Sabotaging 'American Idol'
FOX execs think someone is trying to sabotage "American Idol" by dragging Jennifer Lopez through the mud ... well-connected sources tell TMZ.
FOX execs at the highest level have been complaining that the negative stories about Lopez -- who should be signing on the dotted line any day to become the 3rd judge -- are being planted by people with a grudge against "A.I." and people who are in direct competition with the show.
There have been a number of stories about Lopez's alleged "diva demands" -- that she's demanding way too much money and insisting on movie deals -- but we're told the negotiations have actually been "normal." We're told there is a movie component to the deal -- as well as the possibility of other TV projects -- but the centerpiece has always been "Idol."
Our sources say it's all but a done deal ... and that Lopez will be at the judge's table next week for "A.I." auditions.
More American Idol
Joe Perry Ninja Attack on 'American Idol'
Joe Perry is continuing to blast his Aerosmith bandmate Steven Tyler over his new "American Idol" gig -- but now, Joe's done dragged the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles into the feud.
Perry went off on Tyler during an interview with the Calgary Herald -- saying, "It's his business, but I don't want Aerosmith's name involved with [American Idol]. We have nothing to do with it."
Perry added, "[Idol] is a reality show designed to get people to watch that station and sell advertising ... it's one step above Ninja Turtles."
As for the future of the band, Perry once again threatened to replace Tyler -- saying, "[You've got] four guys that are great together, and if you find the right singer, there's no reason you can't go and entertain people."
For the record -- the Ninja Turtles also used to sing ...
More Aerosmith
Kara DioGuardi -- Fired From 'American Idol'
FOX is finally telling people what TMZ told you five weeks ago -- Kara DioGuardi has been fired from "American Idol" ... actually, FOX isn't using the word "fired," but that's exactly what happened.
In a statement released by FOX, DioGuardi said, "I felt like I won the lottery when I joined 'American Idol' two years ago, but I feel like now is the best time to leave 'Idol.'"
As we first reported, FOX decided long ago to 86 DioGuardi but kept her in the dark until recently.
As we reported yesterday, the last touches are being put on the Jennifer Lopez deal ... it should be finalized next week.
More American Idol
Jennifer Lopez 'American Idol' Deal Imminent
Jennifer Lopez is in the final stages of negotiations with "American Idol" -- and we're told it's all but a done deal and Jennifer will be the last critical link in the chain.
Sources connected to the negotiations tell TMZ ... contrary to some news reports ... there has been no drama and no diva demands. As one source puts it, "It's been typical negotiating."
We're told ... absent a last-minute snag (which is highly unlikely) ... the deal could be inked as early as next week.
"Idol" sources say producers believe Jennifer is the key to re-energizing the show.
More J.Lo
'American Idol' Contestant -- Charges Imminent
UPDATE: We are now told by the L.A. City Attorney, that Asia'h Epperson from "American Idol" will probably be charged tomorrow with misdemeanor battery.
We were initially told the charges were filed today, but the City Attorney tells us the complaint will most probably go to the court after a hearing tomorrow.
As TMZ first reported, the singer was cuffed early in the morning on August 12 for allegedly roughing up another girl in the bathroom at Colony nightclub.
Asia'h claims the alleged victim got a little too
pushy on her way to the toilet ... and the former
"Idol" contestant says she was forced to defend
herself and her sister.
See also
'Idol' Reject Refiles Lawsuit, Now Only Wants $100 Mil
Ian Benardo -- the former "American Idol" contestant who sued the show for $300 million -- has withdrawn that lawsuit ... only to refile a new one for $100 million.
Benardo refiled his lawsuit for workplace discrimination and sexual harassment today in federal court. The original suit was filed with the NY State Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
A rep for Benardo says he was advised that the case was not under the jurisdiction of NY's EEOC -- and instead he had to take the matter to federal court. Benardo is suing because he claims "Idol" producers exploited his sexual orientation and told him to "gay it up."
As for why he dropped his astronomical demand from $300 mil to $100 mil -- Benardo's rep inexplicably says it was a "cleaner amount."
Then again, $100 gazillion is also pretty clean.
See also
Steven Tyler -- Fury After Friend Put in Choke Hold
Aerosmith frontman Steven Tyler was furious last night -- lashing out at a rowdy group of autograph seekers after a shoving match broke out ... and one of Tyler's "guys" was choked out.
The insanity began when Tyler arrived at the Trump Hotel in New York -- and was instantly rushed by the aggressive autograph hounds.
When Tyler's associate began to shove back ... someone reached in from behind and started to choke him out.
Tyler instantly broke up the mess, restored calm ... and then proceeded to lecture the group about standard protocol for autograph seeking.
Tyler and his friend were then escorted into the building by security.
More Aerosmith
Fantasia on Overdose -- I Wanted to Die
Fantasia Barrino claims she knew exactly what she was doing when she pounded a bottle of Aspirin and overdosed earlier this month -- she was trying to kill herself.
In an interview with VH1, 26-year-old Fantasia claims she was so depressed about all of the drama surrounding her relationship with a married man ... that, "I didn't have any fight in me. I didn't care about anything. I just wanted out."
Fantasia added, "At that moment, I wanted out. I wanted it to be over with – all of it, all of that [expletive]."
She went on, "I just sat in the closet and looked at the mirror and took all the pills in the bottle. I wanted to go to sleep and just be at peace. I knew exactly what I was doing. You can't accidentally take a whole bottle of pills."
As we previously reported, a friend called 911 soon after the "American Idol" champ popped the pills -- and she was transported to a local hospital ... where she was treated and eventually released.